It's not condescension, it's a dose of reality. You just don't like to hear the truth because it doesn't fit with your preconceived notions.
PCL, let's keep in context. Are you not the one on these boards who many times convincingly pumps up ALPA, but yet you seem unwilling to adhere to it's own CoE when dealing with confrontation those who disagree with you?
Yes, truth is confrontational. Truth demands confrontation.
"Do unto others as you would have them do to you." There is some REAL truth.
The context of these posts about ALPA vs. USAPA has gone beyond "I disagree with you, here is why..." It has degenerated in to name calling and out and out juvenile posts. You're a current/former ALPA officer, right? If so, you not only represent the profession as a flight officer, you represent ALPA, as does PHX and others who regularly post here. I disagree with your post(s). All I expect is for you to respond professionally. I would think as a strong supporter of ALPA, you would excercise the ideals of the ALPA CoE. That's all. We disagree...and walk away to come back another day...maybe even find common ground.
Example: "AWA gets a windfall from Nic." (The statement is rhetorical for the context of this post, I'm not looking for a thread hijack.)
It can be simple to respond to the above statement. Back it up with factual data and refute or agree. Keep it accurate, stay away from personal denigration. If a person can't, they should say so, and STOP. If they sense that their opposition has a character flaw, they should articulate it professionally. Instead of "you're a ________, I would suggest that they should just state that they understand the perspective, but respectfully, it would be inappropriate to comment further without a bad comment.
If a person really senses that they have the moral high ground, they have nothing to fear. If they really believe that the AAA pilots are wrong, for example, that will play out. If they (AAA) are wrong, if everything they (AWA) state is true, then Nic will stand. That is what I expect from a professioanal ALPA aviator, not name calling and condescending comments.
Years ago I worked for a carrier who, during contract negotiations, the management team made some bad choices that negatively affected the pilot group pay. I worked with a fellow Captain who vowed he was gonna "rip off the company" by some unprofessional tactics to recoup his pay loss. I commented to him, "Are you not doing the same thing you despise your own employer for? Are you not lowering yourself to their level?" I told him the carrier would not survive if it conducted itself that way, anyway.
Different scenario, but similar to the USAPA/ALPA/AWA/USAIRWAYS situation. I think it will play out, but the pilots will either work together, or work separately, the latter, I believe to have grave consequenses.
T8