With all due respect I don't think you understand what pbs will due to you especially if we don't get additional flying. Unless you are in the top 30%. I've gained on vacation with pbs? I turn one week into at least 15-17 days off for 75hrs pay and have hit as high as 20 days. I am not sure if it will jump from 2 to 8-9%, that's a pretty high jump.
Froom what I have seen at this point, you'd do about as well with the Pref Bid system being looked at. How many hour do you fly when you stretch the vacation to 15-17? As it stands now, you'll be able to drop down to 50 and still get paid guarantee.
8-9%? I believe we are very able to reach that number. The amount money that was spent on short term goals was significant when you take into account all the things ASA has done for long term pay offs. The A-Tech (Who named that thing anyhow? It is worse than our call sign!) for example represents a huge investment that will payoff over time in the form of a lower lease cost. At our current staffing, it won't happen but once we get some movement and iron out a few issues, we may return to those sorts of levels (granted Obama doesn't complete flatten the market).
At least you've offered some solutions instead of simply trashing the idea. I understand your angst about PBS. ALPA spent quite a bit of time telling us PBS was a bad thing and then they jump out of the closet and yell, "PBS". There will be some more uncomfortable things we will have to deal with, but I believe we can achieve these goals and make this place an extremely viable place to work for a long time to come.