The Profit Sharing plan at Skywest, Performance Rewards I think it's called, was introduced three years ago. ASA is still trying to catch up to that one. Same holding company. ASA got about 75% of the Skywest program with their new contract. Maybe they'll catch up with their next contract. There are some that doubt the 75% number but they don't understand their own contract yet. Anyway, ASA almost caught up with Skyweest with their last contract on that program so does that count for Skywest "setting the bar?"
The proposed pay scale at Skywest essentially equals the pay scale at ASA. 1 % COLA in each scale. Payscales essentially the same. Would you expect Skywest Inc. to offer Skywest pilots a whole lot more than they just agreed to pay ASA pilots? If so, why? What sense would it make for Skywest Inc. to pay Skywest pilots a whole lot more than ASA pilots? Because Skywest pilots think they "deserve" it? What sense would it make for Skywest pilots to expect a whole lot more form Skywest Inc.?
Reject it! Send it back to SAPA to "negotiate" more. What do you expect the outcome to be? A whole lot more? Why?
Ok, then. Reject it because you "deserve" more. Once you get past that emotional reaction, take a deep breath and look around and see where you are. How'd that work out when the offer was rejected in November, 2005? A year later, a new scale was approved in 2006. The new scale went into effect in January, 2007. Skywest pilots ought to reject this one because they "deserve" more. Right. See where that gets you. If you don't learn from history, you're doomed to repeat it. What's the history?