My response was "so if Aloha was to go under, is it fair or right for a pilot of your experience to start on the very bottom of another seniority list as an FO making 25k a year?" "Well, it wouldn't be right, but it is what it is."
Whoa! It would not be right or fair? Why? and what is the fix?
Recall this is America... you know capitalism, free market society etc... cut throat market competition. If we were small business owners then we'd glee when our competition ran out of business.
I agree it is not fair. I've been furloughed twice. But instead of one person getting a raw deal you are suggesting that it roll down hill and others get the same raw deal as well...
I never expected my fellow pilot at another carrier to accept the consequences of my failed CEO and is weak business plan.
Why should a fellow pilot that was smart or lucky enough not to get hired at Aloha have to feel the pain of Aloha's problems????
My point is that ALPA is outdated and has outlived its usefulness.
Wrong! You blame ALPA yet too many pilots support a gov't that advocates cut throat competition.
USAPA has its own problems, and will most likely fail even if voted in, but I have to give them credit for at least thinking outside the box even if it's wrong.
Are you serious? you are giving credit for what you concede is wrong???
Thinking outside the box is something that ALPA could NEVER do, and that's why it's outdated, and it needs to go.
As soon as ALPA goes outside the box then its creditbility suffers.
Look, ALPA, a labor union, doesn't have the political support and power to go outside the box. Why do you expect it to?
But if you want to condone ALPA, then what kind of outside the box thinking should ALPA do?
National Sen List? How... NO ONE CAN SHOW US HOW!!
SOS? HOW!! Pilots think demonstrations are weak!!
Gov't? HOW? Pilots vote for Bush and McCain!!
ALPA is not gov't. ALPA is not power. Labors strength comes from consensus. That is why speaking out against ALPA in public makes it easy for gov't and CorpAmerica to divide us.
If you are having issues with your spouse, you don't go public or send a broadcast email to the WHOLE family!!
The reason why MLK jr was effective was he got all of his people to stop riding the buses. His "dream" speech would be unknown if it weren't the unified masses who showed up....
As long as you keep acting like a small business owner, Corp America will continue to play us....