SkyWstman said:
Management's job has never changed. Their job is to extract every penny of productivity out of the work force.
You are right about that and joining a union will not change that. However, if you manage your union well, you can give management the maximum productivity that the law allows, which is 1000 flight hours per year, under jointly agreed and controlled conditions in which
you have a legal voice than cannot be ignored. Today, you have no legal voice at all in anything!
Do I think you all should join a union? Yes, I do and have for many years.
Will it solve all your problems overnight? NO, it will not do that and it probably will NEVER solve all of your problems. The big difference will be that the Company will not be able to change whatever you agree to without your consent. That's very different from the status quo.
Your "first contract" will probably be inferior to many other contracts. That's usually the case, but it will be a legal contract, not an "understanding" that the Company can change at will.
As an outsider, I don't think you have any reason to complain about not getting your expected 18-month change in 70-seat pay. You never had a "TA" that you keep talking about. You never had a "contract" and you don't have one now. The Company can change your pay to whatever it wants, whenever it wants. It can do that to any other make-believe "agreement" that you have.
As long as you are not members of a union with a legally negotiated contract, you are "employees at will." You may think you have a seniority sytem but the fact is you do not. Today, your seniority is whatever the Company says it is, whether you like it or not. You can pretend all you want but that is a legal fact; you have no real seniority. If tomorrow they decide to take it away the only legal choice you have is to quit. The truth is the majority of you aren't going to do that no matter what management does, and you can bet they know it.
ALPA has a great many problems, particularly as it relates to its regional pilot membership. Neverthless, if you decide to join a union, ALPA is definitely the best game in town. It is literally miles ahead of whomever is in second place, regardless of all its many faults.
ALPA can't and isn't going to get you a "great contract". Whatever contract you eventually get will depend on SkyWest pilots, not on ALPA. The difference is simple: when you do get a contract, it will be a real contract and legally binding on both you and the Company.
Yes, the company can still violate your "real contract" just as it violates the make-believe agreement that you have now. However, you WILL have legal recourse with a union. At present the only recourse you have is to pout, which is YOUR fault. You have had several opportunities to organize and rejected them all, so there is no one to blame for the things you are complaining about other than yourselves. That's what you wanted (in the majority) and that's exactly what you have, i.e., nothing.
When you have a union, you can still have a lousy contract if that is what you choose to negotiate. MESA is a good example of that. However, MESA pilots did NOT have to accept that contract, it was a choice that THEY made. Granted they were "set up" both by their management and the actions of ALPA. Be that as it may, they are the one's that decided to take what they have. They did not have to do so. You can follow in their footsteps if you choose or you can do much better if you wish.
When the XJT pilots were talking about getting into ALPA I had a lot to say about it that they did not like. Many of them interpreted what I said as being anti-ALPA. They were wrong. I was not against them joining ALPA, I was against them doing it as a part of the CAL MEC. Now that they've figured out that was not in their best interests and have their own MEC, they are doing just fine. They had one of the worst contracts under the IACP (again mostly because it was a CAL union, not theirs.) Today, as independent members of ALPA, the XJT pilots have negotiated one of the BEST contracts in the regional industry. They are proud members of the ALPA
in their own right and you would do well to take their advice.
If you are going to become unionized, my adivice would be the same as theirs: join the ALPA and do it now. No matter what contract you ultimately get for yourselves, the other benefits of the ALPA are more than worth the dues you will pay. Just one serious medical problem, or one threat to your license from the FAA, one "fender-bender" of an incident, and you'll learn in a heartbeat the value of being a member of the ALPA. An independent union does have its advantages but, for a small airline, which you are, the disadvantages outweigh them. The ALPA is the best way to go, IMO.
Just think about this as the last example. What will you do if tomorrow SkyWest buys or creates another airline that does NOT include you? How will a totally powerless organization like SAPA deal with that? Answer: You would not have a leg to stand on. They can wipe you out, transfer your airplanes and your flying with the stroke of a pen and there would be absolutely nothing that you could even TRY, legally, to do about it. Think it can't happen? Don't bet on it!
Yes, I have a self-interest. The fact is that as long as you remain a non-union airline, your pilot group is a potential threat to mine and to every other unionized pilot group, large or small. My group has already felt the impact of your very unwise compensation decision and so have countless other "union" pilots. So, it is true that it would be better for the rest of us if you decide to join a union.
The bottom line is: it would also be better for you.
Best wishes.