Have seen a lot of responses from xjt folks; it is true that they have recently signed a superior CBA, and although they did have a strategic preparedness (strike) committee up and running, they did not come close to a release or a release date. Why? A solid mec, strike committee, and a management team that must have been receptive to quality of life issues and how they impact the bottom line and the operation as a whole.
At xj, our mgmt. stonewalled right up to a deadline, and then only signed after we let pay and other issues go. They effectively used a whipsaw airline to force us to make scope our biggest priority, for which we sacrificed many goals. Our mec and negotiators took a lot of heat for not calling the strike(they kept talking for a day, shutting the airline down without a strike...) but have recently been vindicated by refusing to accept concessions for growth. And we (recently) got the growth anyway. SUrprise, surprise...
These accountant/attorney/management types are rewarded for squeezing performance and low costs out of their employees, and they have no problem with you giving up family life, career goals, and compensation to help them.
ALPA has a lot of problems, but would I want to be working for mesaba, or nwa without them, NO WAY. The legal representation, medical and insurance resources are invaluable. As long as the relationship between alpa and mgmt. is constructive, it is a win-win. The alpa committee structure saves mgmt. from many problems, if the membership gets involved. And that is the final word, your union's effectiveness is only as good as the commitment from the pilots YOU elect to represent you, and your willingness to invest time and effort to get involved. Good Luck! When winter here lasts for 5 months, i still wish I had tried harder to get on at Skywest!