Thats EXACTLY what needs to happen. I emailed my state and local reps about this a couple days ago. Imagine that, requiring pilots to have a *GASP* Airline Transport Pilot rating to fly as an Airline Pilot. Crazy i know

The airlines can now just hire anyone they want often without even a sim evaluation just to get a warm body to fill a required seat. Force them to hire people with an ATP, people who have shown they can fly to Airline Transport Pilot standards (i know another gasp) then the airlines will have to raise pay to attract actual qualified pilots. That would also help get rid of alot of the zero to hero pilot factories. This absolutely needs to be what happens.
Heyas Super,
While we are at it, we should raise the TT requirement for CFIs beyond that for a commerical ticket as well. You should have SOME experience before you start signing off newbies, but that's an argument for another time.
I like the ATP requirement for new hires. In the past, the industry was self-regulating...mainly due to a hold-over of principals from the regulated era. Mainlines still flew the vast majority of the RPMs, and THEY had strict requirements. It was still the "golden ring".
The result was that there were always EXPERIENCED pilots looking to get on at the commuters, so they also had tight requirements. When I got hired at Henson, I had 3000TT, with 1400 scheduled, 135 turbine, and I was one of the low time guys in class. You had to pay your dues at every step. Instruct, cargo, charter, etc...
BTW, anyone who thinks that a 300TT civilian guy is as competent as a 300TT military guy, or a 1500TT civilian guy is feeding you a line of brainwashed hooey. And for those who chant "well, they hired 300 hour guys in the 60's"....sure, but those guys got hired as FLIGHT ENGINEERS, and sat there for a couple years being watched closely.
Now you are seeing the financial fallout in the industry coming home to roost. The mainline jobs, while still relatively decent, are no longer the lottery ticket they once were, so the interest downstream has also fallen off. When the expansion of the regionals, coupled with the crappy QoL/Pay led to a LACK of applicants, they had to drive hiring requirements down to a wet commerical and a pulse. Except now these guys are not riding sideways for a few years under the supervision of a major airline training program, but are being turned loose with captains with barely more experience than themselves.
Since the industry cannot or will not self-regulate any longer, then it's time to impose a minimum. The really interesting thing will be the unintended consequences (and there ALWAYS is). IMHO, in the current envrionment, you will be unable to find the number of ATP pilots needed, even with higher pay, because there simply will not be the bodies. To go from 250 hours to 1500 hours CFIing is going to take a LOT of time, magnified by all the additional people trying to teach. Sure, you can pay for it, but that's REALLY expensive, and number people is already getting reduced by the expense of flying. Fly frieght! Sure! Too bad Air21 nuked the cancelled check business, and there are only so many urine samples to fly.
The regionals will be FORCED to hang onto the people they have, otherwise they'll simply collapse (a good thing). When they start paying more for their pilots, the other employee groups will say "me too!", and their costs will skyrocket, and sooner or later the mainline partner will say "hey, we can do it ourselves cheaper, and have a better product", and simply let the contracts lapse, to whatever extent they can't get out of them for bad performance (also a good thing).
I really hope they make this a requirement, because of all the trouble it will cause for the regionals. And trouble is fun to watch, as long as it's not your trouble...now where is my popcorn and beer?
Nu