I didn't think you meant it that way. Look, if a pilot is tired, he shouldn't fly. That is something we can all agree on. As a furloughed pilot, I want to be recalled ASAP, and I think no one should fatigue unless he is too tired to fly.
As for Hopalong's post and your comment about him fatiguing to "help out our furloughed brethren", I read that he is fatiguing "when necessary" i.e. when he is too tired to fly, to help us out. He did not say he was abusing the policy. If pilots are flying tired, then the company will staff accordingly, with LESS PILOTS. If they are calling it quits for the day because they are being worked too hard or having their rest shifted and flying nights when they began their tour in the daytime, or whatever makes them tired, they should tell the company they are too tired. That would indicate the company LEGITIMATELY needs more pilots.