Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
So what you want is for a student to tie up a busy CTAF frequency (which is often the same as UNICOM) to get an airport advisory because they can't figure out from the wind and local traffic what the current runway is?zeroline said:Dont be so quick to judge. CFI's have to teach their students how to request an airport asdvisory. When your student flys once a week on saturday when every uncontrolled airports pattern in the area is busy as $h!t, you cant only have him/her listen to the radio to figure out whats going on in the pattern. Sure, thats what they should do. But, because of primacy, if thats all they do, thats alll they WILL EVER do. They will never ask for a traffic advisory unless you make sure they do it every once in a while. This scenario often happens to be the case more often than not.
Does this refer to people who don't scan and spend too much time reading the instruments rather than looking outsite (I have this problem and I am trying to break it) or something else?Flight_Line said:[font="]Pilots who fly IFR VFR.
[/font]
No, it refers to the guy who blasts off into the soup VFR.dseagrav said:Does this refer to people who don't scan and spend too much time reading the instruments rather than looking outsite (I have this problem and I am trying to break it) or something else?
I assume zero flight instructed in Southern Cali or DC area or a busy are like the two.(they are extremely busy especially on the weekend) I have ran into the same problem that was stated. There is nothing wrongwith plugging in CTAF/UNICOM and (even though there are two or three aircraft in the pattern) saying to your student, "you want to practice that call to UNICOM to get an airport advisory." Even though you wouldnt do it in the same situation, its important that your student learn how to do it sometime. You have them try it just so they Know how to do it. Which is exactly what zero stated. You should read more carefully next time.pilotman2105 said:So what you want is for a student to tie up a busy CTAF frequency (which is often the same as UNICOM) to get an airport advisory because they can't figure out from the wind and local traffic what the current runway is?
"XYZ traffic, Cessna 12345 entered left downwind for runway 36." That seems pretty self explanatory to me what runway to use.
"XYZ Airport Weather. Wind 360@12..." That seems pretty self explanatory to me, too.
Yeah, the law of primacy is in effect here, but so is common sense. Just because it's the first thing that they've learned that does not mean that it is going to be the only thing that they learn.
I would think that any basic intro to communications at non-towered airports would include the "use common sense" clause. There is no need for an airport advisory, local airport advisory, or whatever the he!! you want to call it. Get the weather yourself, listen to traffic, and use your brain to make a decision.
DCMartin said:I assume zero flight instructed in Southern Cali or DC area or a busy are like the two.(they are extremely busy especially on the weekend) I have ran into the same problem that was stated. There is nothing wrongwith plugging in CTAF/UNICOM and (even though there are two or three aircraft in the pattern) saying to your student, "you want to practice that call to UNICOM to get an airport advisory." Even though you wouldnt do it in the same situation, its important that your student learn how to do it sometime. You have them try it just so they Know how to do it. Which is exactly what zero stated. You should read more carefully next time.
That's exactly what I'm saying.....at my home airport, the taxiways are about 200ft wide at the point where they intersect with the runway. This is plenty of room for airplanes to taxi around each other. If the guy behind you calls in ready because you were waiting for the guy on short final to land, you just got leap frogged. Calling in ready is how you "get in line" so to speak.Maybe I misunderstand what you're trying to say, but if you're number one at the hold bars waiting for traffic and the guy behind you calls ready to go-- he might get cleared, but in most cases he's not going to be able to go around you to get to the runway. That's a pretty good way to piss off a controller I would imagine. Of course, this is all a moot point if everyone just waited until they were number one before they called ready to depart.
This was the whole point of my first post "DONT BE SO QUICK TO JUDGE" Just because someone is doing something differently than the way you do it dont assume the person is doing something wrong. You have to be dynamic as a pilot and especially as an instructor. You cant teach every one the same way. I would very much like to take a student to a non-busy non-towered airport and teach them calls but some circumstances dont allow it. This goes for alot of things like for example: wide patterns. Before I was an instructor I used to get so pissed when people flew wide patterns or extended further than I liked. But after instructing for a while you learn why sometimes its necessary to fly an extended pattern.TonyC said:The last several posts highlight my biggest peeve, and it has to do with instructing.
I hate it when an Instuctor insists that HIS technique is the BEST technique, it's the ONLY technique that anyone should use, and you should treat it as a PROCEDURE. If you plan to please said Instructor and be passed on the ride by said Instructor, you very well better use the Instructor's technique and none other.
It belies a weakness in the character and knowledge of the Instructor, and it does the student a disservice.
(SECOND VERSE: Apply same to Captain / First Officer relationship.)
Is this the wrong place for the obvious Fight Club joke? ^_^apdsm said:Pilot's who talk about flightinfo.com all the time...
I always thought the second verse was the same as the first. "I'm Henery the Eighth I am, Henery the Eighth I am, I am. I got married to the widow next door, she's been married seven times before.....etc. etc......"TonyC said:The last several posts highlight my biggest peeve, and it has to do with instructing.
I hate it when an Instuctor insists that HIS technique is the BEST technique, it's the ONLY technique that anyone should use, and you should treat it as a PROCEDURE. If you plan to please said Instructor and be passed on the ride by said Instructor, you very well better use the Instructor's technique and none other.
It belies a weakness in the character and knowledge of the Instructor, and it does the student a disservice.
(SECOND VERSE: Apply same to Captain / First Officer relationship.)
Students require a set method and concrete procedure to learn anything. If you say "this is the way that I do it, but you can do it how you want," then the student (especially an inexperienced one) will change his/her pattern each time they do a set task.TonyC said:The last several posts highlight my biggest peeve, and it has to do with instructing.
I hate it when an Instuctor insists that HIS technique is the BEST technique, it's the ONLY technique that anyone should use, and you should treat it as a PROCEDURE. If you plan to please said Instructor and be passed on the ride by said Instructor, you very well better use the Instructor's technique and none other.
It belies a weakness in the character and knowledge of the Instructor, and it does the student a disservice.
(SECOND VERSE: Apply same to Captain / First Officer relationship.)
Funny thing, that song was ringing in the back of my mind even as I typed that.BankAccount=0$ said:I always thought the second verse was the same as the first. "I'm Henery the Eighth I am, Henery the Eighth I am, I am. I got married to the widow next door, she's been married seven times before.....etc. etc......"
Sorry for the misguided attempt at some humor, back to the regularly scheduled Pet Peeve disscussion![]()
There is an FBO at VNY that has the same ops frequency as Eagle in LAX. Every now and then you'll hear some Gulfstream calling to ask about their transportation. I just talk over 'em!Flying Illini said:On to the pet peeve: FBO's who use the airport unicom as their arinc frequency. Do you have any idea how many airports you can hear/reach from 20,000+ feet and 80 miles out on 122.8?! Makes it tough to ensure that you pax have their ride waiting when the freq is congested...and I hate talking on 122.8 because God only knows how many people are hearing you and how much of a freq. congestion problem you're causing. FBO's, get a dedicated arinc freq! Oh yeah, turn up the volume too!