We are dealing with a similar situation at Flight Options and our Union drive. This is how it went down.
When Net Jets got their new contract ratified, and thus an immediate 30 to 50% raise from their current salaries, which put them around 20-30% above our salaries. Our company, Flight Options, said that they did not expect the Net Jets contract to ratify, nor any other fractional to match it., and that it was an unsustainable business model, and that Flight Options would NOT match it.Citation Shares matched that new salary + 1% within a week, which shot down Flight Options' philosophy in both aspects. That put our Union drive into high gear, and our mailbox was overfilling with cards.
In late November /early December, the Union made sure the company heard that we had 60% of our company's pilots' cards - the Teamsters wanted 65% for us to submit a petition to the National Mediation Board (NMB). The NMB only requires 35% - we already had more than enough to have a vote.
When the company heard that, they then announced through company meetings with pilots in our recurrent classes, that they were now "looking at a new compensation package". That was it. No details, but a complete reversal.
Just after Mid December rolled around, and the Union made sure the company heard that we had enough cards to petition the NMB (and then some), and would be doing so right after the first of the year and the holiday season was over. When the company heard that, and ONLY when the company heard that, did they then announce "a new industry-competititve compensation plan would be announced no later than JANUARY 31st".
The company KNEW that we would have already petitioned the NMB by then. It was what they thought, a win-win situation - they hoped that announcement would delay the Union from wanting to petition the NMB, and effectively stall the vote another 30 days, giving the company more time to make all kinds of promises to the pilots to try to sway support for the vote. During a union campaign, time is on the company's side, as they can communicate easier and more effectively than the union can, and the company can promise the moon to sway votes. On the other hand, if the union did petition anyways, they could then claim that they would love to give the pilots a raise, but now that the union interferred by calling a vote, that they had to "freeze" pay, and couldn't do it, making the union look bad and costing the pilots their much-needed raise. It didn't work, our pilots for the most part have seen through the plot.
Our union leaders have told us that this very threat was discussed with the best labor lawyers in the country, and that the lawyers told them that since the announcement of the raise was announced before the NMB was petitioned for a vote, that the company can in fact still give the raise announcement they teased the pilots with - they are NOT obligated to "freeze" and not give that.
The Flexjet pilots' situation is exactly the same thing. The company has now announced their raise plan. Should the Flexjet pilots have enough cards to petition the NMB, the company will in fact be frozen from making any changes, however since the changes in pay were already planned before the petition, they should still be able to implement it.
That is the understanding from the labor attorneys. Whether the management at either company agrees is a different story, and it is quite possible something that could end up in court, and a judge decides who is right.
Just thought I'd let you know that this issue has been addressed to lawyers, and that is what they said, and they should know a lot more than we do. We would expect the management of the companies to play the "we'd love to give you a raise but now we can't" card, because that's their job, to delay any raises, and keep the company's costs down, and if the pilots buy it and don't fight it, they save millions of dollars over the 90-day campaign.
It is a nasty battle, and unfortunately, it is our quality of life that is at stake. It's ugly, but it is management's fault that the battle is here - if we don't fight for ourselves, we know management won't do it, so we have no choice, and Net Jets' contract is proof of the end result of a good fight from the pilots - they won. Now it's our turn.