Wow. Lots of conversation on a post I made
two years ago. Good grief.
It is just important to evaluate WHY you decide not to declare. If your decision is based on pride, looking stupid to your peers, fear of paperwork, over confidence, or in general worrying about some consequence OTHER than the problem at hand then your decision not to declare is tainted.
Absolutely, 100%
CORRECT!
If you have a problem outside of your personal experience level, declare the emergency. Everybody will get out of your way and be happy you made it down safely.
I have no issues with that. I have always espoused the same thing.
However, it also seems that what we have here is a passle of folks who either can't read, or failed to comprehend...so for those who have nothing better to do than reply to two year old threads, what the heck...
Don't be. You'll only get a headache.
I wouldn't be suprised. Two brothers. One an airline pilot, the other a 747 Capt and F-16 pilot in the ANG we're flying their family owned 421 back home after a family vacation. Both families were in the back, lost an engine, never declared an emergency. They flew it 25 minutes to their home base.
Being that the point of these replies has been to worship the almighty holy act of declaring an emergency and to abhor and castigate anyone who would fail to utter the magic mantra, you're talking apples and oranges. I never said a word about not dealing with a problem...I did say that there is absolutely NOTHING magic about "declaring" an emergency.
Don't ever be lulled into thinking there is. The successful outcome of your emergency evoloution is in your hands, not in your microphone; you are responsible for making it happen.
You're describing in the quoted paragraph above, two individuals who are apparently well technically qualified, who elected to pursue a particular course of inaction. That may have been the best course, it may not; you provided no particulars. However, I never advocated that, did I? (for the slow...I did not).
What I did stipulate is that "declaring an emergency" has taken on some sort of mystical aura; an epithet that calls out to the help-gods and sends them scurrying to your aid. The skies change color, your skin tingles, and your dandruff is immediately cleared. Your skin is clearer, and runways around the world open their doors to you, angels sing, and mayors polish the key to the city.
As opposed to simply stating your situation, your intended actions, and then doing your job...flying the airplane and dealing with that situation.
If you're given priority, you're given priority, period. State your situation, and your intentions. You can use the magic "e" word in there if it makes you feel better. When I worked fire on the ground, I knew folks that just loved to run lights and sirens. Some sort of schoolboy fantasy. Sometimes it's warranted, and sometimes not. I liked to slow down, turn the **CENSORED****CENSORED****CENSORED****CENSORED** thing off, and arrive on scene without a headache, one minute slower, and in one piece.
If you state your situation and you don't get the help you desire, you restate it...or not. You've already identified your intentions. You're not asking for straight in to XX runway, you're telling ATC your intentions. And so you should.
Flying for 25 or 50 or 100 miles when it's unnecessary (assuming it were so in your scenario...for all we can do, with the lack of information, is assume), is another matter. That is lack of action. Not merely "not" declaring an emergency, but seemingly ignoring the situation completely. Something I have never advocated. Respond slowly and deliberately, fast hands kill. But respond.
If I was the passenger having a life threatning situatiion such as a heart attack, I would want the pilot declare an emergency and get me help right away.
I imagine you might, but if I were the passenger, I'd want the pilot to get me to help safely, and to do the job to the best of his abilities. Do you suppose that "declaring" an emergency, that magic phrase that makes the angels rush to your side, will make a bit of difference? Or will simply stating your situation and your intentions cover it, instead. Are you going to carry 250 knots to the runway threshold, scream down to the end on smoking brakes, throw out the slides and evacuate the airplane into the waiting arms of salvation with bright, red, flashing lights (all for the want of cuticle removal, or perhaps the ever popular screaming heegeebees)? Fly abnormally and meet the ambulance on the runway, just like an episode of
Emergency, or
Chips? Or just state your intentions, get priority handling, and go?
Me? I'm just going to go.
I've had critical patients on board when flying ambulance, many times. Knowing that use of the term "lifegaurd" will already grant priority, using the magic "e" word seems superfluous. Priority is priority, and you don't get more simply because you use the "e" word.
Folks get excited when they see a fire. They run, they panic. They flip out. The drool, they get short of breath, their thinking and their vision narrows. They even run back into the flame. A professional doesn't do that. A professional walks calmly to the fire, sizes it up, and works it. We are professionals. Not deer frightened with panic.
In the last paragraph you say that if you have a fire, request the trucks and go right for the numbers. My question to you is that if you tell ATC you have a fire, or structural failure, why wouldn't you just tell them that and that you are declaring an emergency? By doing so, you are telling ATC that your aircraft and passengers are in grave danger. You also get the chance to tell them what is going on which could assist the NTSB and the FAA in determining what happened and how to prevent it, because it will be on tape.
Ah, ten-four there, good buddy. I can see where using the "e" word makes it all crystal clear for ATC, the FAA in general, and the NTSB. Good thinking. After all, I merely have suggested identifying clearly your problem, stating your intentions, and then handling it like a professional. Throwing that pesky "e" word in there makes it all different. Generations will learn volumes from the use of that "e" word. Good idea. Now it's all clear as a bell.
I can see where "XXX approach, XXX is making straight in for three four left with an engine fire, request trucks and an ambulance," would not convey the problem at all. ATC would never guess that anybody needs assistance...after all, they might think it's a weenie roast, or a sightseeing tour. Throwing the "e" word in there changes everything. Good thinking!
You also say don't make a mountain out of a molehill.
I do, indeed.
Is a passenger having a heart attack a mountain, or a molehill?
Now, that really depends. There are times, most times, when even the most pressing matter doesn't call for a run, but a walk. After all, rushing is when folks get hurt.
Someone has a fire, and presses the panic button. Let's exercise that emergency descent we were taught as student pilots...lets' get into that little forest clearing right beneath us, because, by golly, we have a gen-u-whine eee-mer-jun-see! Don't take no notice, will ya, that there's no way to get help down there, that you'll set the forest on fire around you, and that there's nothing to put out the fire...just get it down there. Get it done, as they say. Durn goot thinking, there.
Same with that heart attack. Big emergency folks. Everybody look at me. I'm having an emergency. I'm going to rush to the ground right here, put down in this field...after all, a person dying from a heart attack is a whole lot safer over here, behind this hay stack, than in the air...on the way to a runway where help might be waiting. But declaring that "e" word might just bring them back...the smile on their face, the warmth radiating out when that grateful patient hears the "e" word might just restore a shockable rhythm to that person's heart.
Or you could simply contact the local unicom, contact center, contact an approach or tower or other ATC facility, state your situation and intentions, while you act on them. Panic, the traditioned perception that some how the magical calling of a situation an emergency changes the situation miraculously, lies steeped in the wives tale fostered in errol flynn movies of silk scarves and oversexed virile actors.
We're not talking rocket science. You want to use the magic "e" word? If it makes you feel better, you do that. Don't expect great miracles, but use it. Go on.
The point I have made, now and always before, is to handle the situation by whatever means is necessary. If that means using the magic "e" word, then go for it. You know you want to.
Don't forget the lights and sirens. Not only are they pretty at night, they look cool. Right?