Here is a cut and paste of a remark from Some Guy on All Things F9:
According to Republic, most of the Airbus leases expire between 2013-2017, so they have at least three more years (3 are on longer leases).
It would make no sense for Bedford to replace Frontier's aircraft with smaller E190s, and Embraer doesn't have anything bigger. He told industry analysts in December that Republic would refleet the Airbuses either with new Airbuses, Boeing 737-700/800s, or Bombardier CS300s, and that the announcement would come this quarter. But maybe you are right. Maybe Bedford lied.
Regardless of whether any of it is factual, it does allow one to understand the importance of a single seniority list with no fences. IF BB decided to refleet the Airbuses, who's to say he wouldn't put the new aircraft on a different certificate with 'Frontier' colors? New airplanes, cheaper crews.
The best way to protect against that is to enforce a single seniority list, no fences, and hope the arbitrator gives everyone a fair shakeout. If F9 pilots were fenced out of the rest of RAH, the single seniority list would mean nothing (At the very least it provides job security for F9 pilots in the event of furlough/fleet reduction). Without a single seniority list with no fences, there would be no motivation for BB to keep the branded flying at F9 (why pay a senior F9er to fly something he can put with an underpaid RAH employee in F9 colors?). It's already happened at YX. And now YXers will be flying RAH aircraft at RAH wages. The same thing could happen to F9ers.
All the employees that comprise what is now RAH (F9/YX/+) need to work together to improve the wages and work rules there across the board. If F9 and YX worked with their new RAH brothers and sisters (you may not like them but it looks like they're now family), they could collectively improve pay on ALL of the airframes. This would result in livable wages for everyone on the list, and a form of pay/job protection for anyone who could be downgraded from the Airbus in the future; whether that came from fleet reduction/transition, furloughed F9 guys and gals being recalled with no Airbus available in the bid, etc.
Everyone needs to check their egos at the door, and work together as one team to improve pay and QOL at the reverend's expense. One large unified pilot group is going to be MUCH better than a bunch of small, whining, bickering pilot groups that fight with each other over the same piece of pie instead of demanding a larger portion of the pie TOGETHER.
The way I see it? F9 people are worried about maintaining the status quo - at their peril. YX people are appropriately bitter about their situation, but the SLI will eventually happen and they will have jobs. Having a job won't mean anything though, unless the pay is better on all the airframes (so everyone has a livable wage regardless of where they fall on the seniority list after arbitration). 'Original' RAH guys are trying to improve their pay and quality of life. Right now they look at the Frontier pay/lifestyle and want the same. Work to get it for them on their current airframes and they will be content flying what they already are.. and for that matter, F9ers and YXers might not mind flying a 190 (especially if it means being based closer to home). But only IF the pay is good across the board.
OR none of this matters and Southwest and AirTran will eat you alive. If the pay doesn't improve at RAH with their next contract, I hope they do. Maybe it will open up some decent paying pilot positions at Southwest.