Sam Fisher said:
We are no more divided than any other pilot group. Our strike vote results do prove that if the NMB would release us, we would have no problem shutting this place down. The difference between myself and nonstop is that I don't think we will be able to strike anytime soon and in light of that, I want the contract done now. He thinks it is worth waiting for that day, whether it comes or not, so that he can shut this place down. I respect his opinion as an XJT pilot and wish him luck in his quest to shut this place down, despite the fact that I disagree with his viewpoints at this point in time. Rest assured, if the NMB would release us tomorrow, a) we would have far more leverage than we do now and b) I'd walk that picket line day in and day out, until the deal was signed.
Sam
If you are saying that you would accept an unsatisfactory agreement now, merely because you are too impatient and unwilling to wait-out the negotiating process, your thinking is beyond my comprehension.
Negotiations are normally a long an tedious process, and especially at difficult times like these. The NMB deliberately uses the "delay tactic" in an effort to force acceptance of inferior agreements. So does the Company. And so, by the way, does ALPA National. You appear to be letting them take advantage of your impatience.
When the
needs of the pilot group (as opposed to the wants) have not been met and you are considering the possibility of self-help and taking "strike votes", it is not logical to say that you will strike if you can do it now but you will take a bad agreement if you have to wait. Pardon me, but that doesn't make sense.
You should never point a loaded gun (strike vote) at the Company's head unless the group is fully prepared to pull the trigger. Without complete unity of purpose, which I don't find in this thread, pulling the trigger is suicide.
Unity doesn't mean that every pilot must agree on every line in the contract. However, it does mean that the group must agree on what your "needs" really are. If you do in fact agree on the "needs", it follows you will also be willing to wait however long it takes until they are achieved AND to walk away if they are not.
IMHO, something as drastic as a strike is never warranted to satisfy your wants but is sometimes necessary to obtain your needs. If the difference between wants and needs is not clear to the group the success of a strike is unlikely.
JMO. Again, I wish you all the very best.