What is the lawsuit about now??? Hide behind DFR all you want, but the Short answer: money. The union has it - someone else wants it.
Work it out within the union & let the money stay where it will serve all of us, not just the RJDC windfallees (wc).
ALL that aside. Truce. White Flag. Whatever on the RJDC, 'cause it's going nowhere & I don't really care.
Sorry (really sorry) but you asked the question and your civil debate deserves a thoughtful reply.
The lawsuit is about Representation. Your confusion about "representation" is understandable because you probably have not seen it. You are not alone, ALPA's senior leadership, including Mr. Woerth were unable to describe what a "Fiduciary Duty" is when deposed on their obligations to their membership.
So illustrate things in more concrete terms, how about a balance of power? A judiciary where disputes between MEC's could be resolved? How about no more jets for jobs cram downs and no more Compass / Mesaba debacles?
MEC's need to work together, both when it is convenient and particularly when it is inconvenient. ALPA decided that regionals were not going to get effective scope because mainline MEC's deemed it a threat to their power. Now this policy has come full circle and
Delta's and NorthWest's rates on similar equipment undermine ASA, while
ASA's airplanes are being transferred out of the ALPA's membership. I don't care who you are or where your career is going, the Northwest MEC Chairman said it best when he proclaimed that flying at NorthWest would never return to the career it was.
ALPA (representing Comair, ASA and Delta) was in negotiations with Delta on all three carriers simultaneously for years. How easy would it have been to stop the erosion of Delta's flying while preserving the security of pilots then? In fact, serious discussions about tripartied negotiations did happen. However, ALPA lacked the structure to make it happen. Fixing that structure so that pilots have a voice when their wages and working conditions are being negotiated is what the litigation is about.
ALPA has no obligation to SkyWest, or Chautauqua, or Republic Pilots. But they seem to reap most of the benefits of ALPA's infighting. ALPA desperately needs a way to prevent MEC's from negotiating in a predatory fashion to harm other ALPA members. In fact, our new EVP Tom Zebarini proposed a resolution to stop MEC's from negotiating phantom pay rates on each other's airplanes. This is good, but we need coordination from the top of ALPA's structure to come together as a cohesive force to restore our profession.
OK, I'm willing to call a truce if you are
~~~^~~~