UAX Letter to UAL Pilots over jumpseat dispute.

[trachyte11]

Again... the big question.. is.... who is obligated to fix the computer code? And where is that obligation written?

I am still curious as to how the UAL pilots and/or MEC is a part of this.... Did they agree or commit to fixing this?

Do some research. UAL MEC is exactly who is responsible for the priority in the current software. UAL MEC asked their management to implement the current priority. Most UAL pilots don't expect to have priority on UAX airplanes. However, there are a few on the UAL MEC who think otherwise.

The software was changed. UAX has asked/negotiated to have it changed back. The response for some time now has been that it is not financially beneficial to UAL. So, they see no reason to change it. UAX jumpseat committee (not just skywest) has decided to give them a reason.

 

[Caspian27]

How about a grassroots movement?

www.uaxjumpseatpriority.net



The ALPA BOD is coming up this Fall... why not use some political movement there...

The first I've heard of this is on FI via the "letter". Why was there no threads just explaining the situation so everyone can understand the issues?

And now the letter was written by a OO pilot who will remain nameless? What is the UAL MEC supposed to do.. go to management with a moniker letter and say "some one wrote this... can you make changes?". It doesn't work this way....

Most people are willing to help others out under the guise of respect and trust. Building positive relationships does more to get things done than "letters".

Does it take time? Sure does. But actively choosing to get off the high road and go for the low road isn't going to work.... well... let's see.... what July 31?

Who responds to threats in a positive way even if the core message is valid?

Rez,

My understanding is the letter was written by the JSC's of all the carriers who signed the letter (every UAX except TSA).

As far as relationships and time like you mentioned, again my understanding is they've (UAX JSC's & UA) have been working on this for about 2 years. So the relationship was there...the time spent trying to solve the issue without "threats" as you say, was there.

My understanding is, those things didn't work...then in May, apparently UALPA (again totally 3rd party info since I'm not a rep) requested a change in the computer priorities. (The change is a fact. According to the computer, UA has priority on ALL flights mainline or express, followed by TSA & GoJet. Whether UALPA was the driving force behind this is again, 3rd party party info, but they benifted from the change...)

In any case, it seems like the JS reps have worked long & hard together and gotten nowhere dealing with UA or UALPA on this. They've already used your suggestions, what else is left?

I'd just like to retain priority on my own birds...that's it. I hold no animosity towards any pilot group.

In addition, I think I'm going to put my name in to be a rep...

 

[Rez O. Lewshun]

So the UAL MEC is sticking it to the UAX pilots? Why?

 

[Gr82Aviate]

So the UAL MEC is sticking it to the UAX pilots? Why?

Why don't you ask them?

 

[JoeMerchant]

So the UAL MEC is sticking it to the UAX pilots? Why?

Because mainline pilots believe they own the regionals...You're a United pilot...at least for a little while...why don't you tell us why the UAL MEC believes they should have priority....

 

[Rez O. Lewshun]

Why don't you ask them?

Actually the intent was to see if the UAX guys knew why...

It is apparent that there is plenty of misunderstanding on both sides.....

It seems that this letter has exacerbated the situation not improved it....

Cooler heads?

 

[JoeMerchant]

Actually the intent was to see if the UAX guys knew why...

It is apparent that there is plenty of misunderstanding on both sides.....

It seems that this letter has exacerbated the situation not improved it....

Cooler heads?

You're a United pilot Rez....Explain the reason for us....We're all ears....

 

[PCL_128]

You're a United pilot Rez....Explain the reason for us....We're all ears....

I don't think Rez has ever said where he works. Maybe you're making ass-umptions?

 

[JoeMerchant]

I don't think Rez has ever said where he works. Maybe you're making ass-umptions?

He's at United now....

 

[PCL_128]

He's at United now....

Like I said. Ass-umptions.

 

[SaturnPilot]

As impossible as, say, USAPA?

An independent major union and an independent regional union are two very different things financially. The regionals do not collect enough dues money to function normally and are actually subsidized by the majors. An airline the size of Skywest and ASA would take in roughly a quarter million dollars a year. One year of contract negotiations alone costs upwards of a half million...add in the rest of the costs of running a union on top of that.

 

[JoeMerchant]

An independent major union and an independent regional union are two very different things financially. The regionals do not collect enough dues money to function normally and are actually subsidized by the majors. An airline the size of Skywest and ASA would take in roughly a quarter million dollars a year. One year of contract negotiations alone costs upwards of a half million...add in the rest of the costs of running a union on top of that.

What if multiple regional airlines were to join? ALPA is going to lose a lot of members over the next year and will probably have to raise dues to cover the losses.....

How did you come up with your numbers....I came up with roughly 3.2 million dollars that ASA/Skyw would come up with in dues....Obviously we are both estimating, but they are far off....

 

[SaturnPilot]

Well, what other impetus or motivation is there for UAL to change it's computer boarding priority at this point? This has been going on for 2 years. They've apparently tried every other avenue and it didn't work. They tried to work together to fix them like you suggest, but that was unsuccessful.

When everything else fails, and the priority is still not right, what else can you do? I like this as little as everyone else...but it is super-frustrating trying to commute on UAX due primarily to this issue.

If this is the case, then I agree something else needs to be done. The issue obviously needs to be fixed. My only point is that the letter is most likely not going to be as successful because it is given as an ultimatum. If the intention of this letter was to simply educate the UAL pilots about the dispute in order to bring resolution, it probably would have worked well had it not included the "or else"...just my opinion.

I hope cooler heads at the top prevail and are able to resolve this problem quickly, because the only people to suffer are going to be the commuters.

 

[Speedtape]

Easy with your Rosa Parks civil disobedience talk.... Are you willing to NOT "ride the bus" as the black community did. What does that mean? Refusing to fly? You gonna do a sick out to get the jumpseat?

Hancock, Adams, Jefferson, Franklin, et all, knew they commiting treason to the British Crown, and if unsuccessful they'd hang.


So... what are you really saying?

What I'm really saying is:

Rosa Parks stood up to the establishment or status quo and took a seat where she was not allowed to sit, instead of cowering and sitting where she was expected to sit. Left with no options, the UAX pilots are challenging the establishment or status quo (UALPA and UAL) with the letter and subsequent action if not resolved, instead of saying nothing and taking no action as they are expected to do. The later action, the boycotting of the bus is similar to the UAX pilots denying the jumpseat, should the problem not be resolved by the stated deadline. Both of these actions are similar in that both actions are an attempt to right the wrong!

Hancock, Adams, Jefferson, Franklin and others, took a stand for something that they believed to be right and just. The pilot leadership of Skywest, Mesa, and the other pilot groups who signed the petition, are taking a stand for something they believe to be right and just, and are taking action to try and correct the wrong.

Rez,
If you took a job at UAL, you have bigger things to worry about than UAX pilots requesting the application of a fair and just, reciprocal jumpseat agreement. That's what I really mean! Good Luck!

 

[SaturnPilot]

What if multiple regional airlines were to join? ALPA is going to lose a lot of members over the next year and will probably have to raise dues to cover the losses.....

I guess you'd have to exclude regionals like CommutAir, Colgan, GoJet:laugh:, PSA, Great Lakes, etc as they are too small and would greatly drain your finances. If multiple regionals joined a regional union then you'd have a bunch of airlines, that previously had to be subsidized by major airlines, on their own.

How did you come up with your numbers....I came up with roughly 3.2 million dollars that ASA/Skyw would come up with in dues....Obviously we are both estimating, but they are far off....

Yearly MEC account income for a regional airline slightly smaller than ASA.