Resume Writer
Registered User
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2004
- Posts
- 1,121
RVR, I cannot speak for the other prep people on this board, but I believe if you check my posts, you will see that I have said that not everyone needs prep. I have never said that people cannot do it on their own.RVR300 said:I think it's absolutely brilliant these prep courses. They've made you all think you can't possibly be good enough to do it on your own.
Like it or not, the people that sit on hiring boards, for the most part, are judging every answer that someone provides. As I said before, (and as SWInflight said) if someone does not know how to tell a story, then it makes the job much more difficult for the interviewer. I do not give people "spring-loaded" answers. I teach them to tell a story effectively.For my part, I'd rather talk to someone and hear what's really going on inside them then a springloaded answer given to them by a prep service.
Part of being a professional in the interview prep business (not just someone that does this as a hobby), is the amount of time spent talking with HR people, reading up on the subject and helping people to frame stories that will help them; not hurt them.
Do I assist people with challenges in their background? Absolutely! Should someone not be given another chance because of a poor choice made many years ago? I don't think so. As long as a person has learned from their mistakes, and is sincere about it, then they deserve another chance.
Let me tell you this. If someone comes to me and has not learned their lesson from a previous mistake or acts cocky, I will call them on it. I tell them how that will appear to the interviewer and how they will blow their chances. Ultimately, if they do not listen to me, I cannot help them. Thankfully, I have been very lucky and have had wonderful people that I have worked with that truly want the help; not just to punch some card saying they did interview prep.
Let's turn that phrase around. Instead of being "disadvantaged," let's say they are being "competitive." As I stated before, no one ever teaches people how to interview. Further, if you have not been on the other side of the desk hiring people, which, by the way, I did for 6 years, then you are at a disadvantage, in my opinion. The behavioral and situational questions are asked for a reason; to obtain an answer from which they can form an opinion about the person's character, leadership and ability to handle problems.What's unfortunate is the feeling here on this forum that you'd be disadvantaged if you don't.
Effective interviewing skills from an HR perspective is something they work on constantly. Do you think that SWA just sends people into the room without any guidelines as to what they are looking for? They have to write their opinions after each question on the form, which is then used in the hiring boards. Those notes are based on perception.
I will agree with you that if someone comes in with "canned answers," then they do not deserve the job. However, if that is what people are doing, then they were not prepped correctly in the first place.
Kathy
Last edited: