Rez O. Lewshun
Save the Profession
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2004
- Posts
- 13,422
A semantic discussion, that's all. I think you're forgetting that there are numerous highly trained, very skilled, hard working and technically proficient blue collar workers out there who need to know as much or more than your average pilot. They certainly don't really obsess about "blue collar vs. professional". There are certainly ways pilots qualify as "professionals", but in the strictest sense, a "white collar professional" doesn't really apply. My opinion, of course.
Once again... professionals look out for the betterment of the public.. they make personal sacrfices for the betterment of the public.
When a doctor gets called at 5am he doesn't say... Naw...I am too tired. Or if a patient can't pay he doesn't withhold medical care..
The choice is up to you..but when you are delayed or extended and your passengers want to get home.. you don't just split and say..my shift is over... see ya.. and leave your pax in the lurch...
In addition ALPA's safety and engineering dept is respected world over... except by its own members... and the accident investigation is in the best interest of the public...paid for by our dues...
Frankly, the technical aspects of being a pilot "profession" are getting easier by the year .. . automation, aircraft reliability, ATC assistance, better weather radar/forecasts, etc. I think the whole ego driven "we pilots are gods of the sky" is sounding increasingly hollow to management, stockholders, and the general public.
It might be..but the new challenge is working together as a team... most accidents occur todays becuase pilots lose SA or they can't work well with others.... coincidental with ALPA affairs?
The only intrinsic quality an aviator needs is GOOD JUDGMENT. Not really "teachable", difficult to define, and is more a factor of age, experience and internal temperament than anything else.
That and good people skills.... which are hard to find.. teamwork... which isn't found here...
On this point, more than anything, unions shoot themselves in the foot big time on this, because in any union, you are a replaceable cog, exactly equal in all respects to every other pilot in the union. Everyone gets treated 100% the same, whether they are the world's most colossal f-up or Space Shuttle material . . it doesn't matter.
Got a better way?
Unions are just terrible at self-policing. Only one crime is unforgivable . . "crossing the union", which is surely an offense, but it's not the only thing they need to address. True "professionals" are very strict on professional standards and will self-police. Poor performing lawyers and doctors routinely face peer boards of inquiry in which they have to defend their right to continue having a license to practice.
Lets be honest here.... have you read the ALPA Code of Ethics? Well? have you ever?
Pilot unions, to my knowledge, have no such boards or self-policing powers, to the ultimate detriment of the entire group.
I guess you haven't....
Very well said....
It depends on your audience...