Having been around the block a few times...well...maybe MORE than jsut a few...:
(1) I don't know ANYONE from Chuck Yeager on down who was born with 1500 hours...EVERYONE has to start somewhere!
(2) Just because people apply for a job where the experience minimums are low doesn't mean that they are all worthless....there will be diamonds in each batch that are good, smart, hardworking and honest people. The problem comes in when management hasn't either the experience, judgment or training to tell the diamonds in the rough from the pea gravel.
(3) The people that DO get through the process and work one of the hardest rows to hoe get some REALLY GOOD hands-on, REAL TIME training (as we used to call it "OJT") working as a freight dawg. I know some VERY good pilots that flew rotten schedules in equipment with more empty holes in the panel than ones with actual instruments in them and did this into "dark airports in Mexico" in all kinds of crappy weather. And what they got out of this trip thought the school of hard knocks was good training, well developed judgement, great stick and rudder skills (autopilot? What's an "autopilot"?) and, if they hung in there for any amount of time and gave it their best..they either developed or were raised in the first place to have a good work ethic.
(4) Folks that come up this way are VERY GOOD candidates for the "cherry" jobs that one can apply for and get if the people doing the selection know what they want and what to look for.
All that having been said.....I came up through the military training/flying/system/standards (prior to doing the corporate thing for another 20 years) and, by nature, tend to want and look for guys that are "just like me, came up through a system with known standards, had to go out and do crazy sh*t in who knows what and where, been there and done that, etc..." but it is damned hard and VERY UNREALISTIC and likely also stupid to ignore a good, hard working, well trained civilian (oooohh..did I just SAY THAT??) FREIGHT DOG!!!!