TonyC
Frederick's Happy Face
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2002
- Posts
- 3,050
Ignorance, lack of information, or self-imposed blindness? I don't know which of these maladies you suffer, but your last three posts bely a fundamental lack of understanding on your part, or a refusal to admit what you know.jbucpt said:hey tony,
where is the "COLLECTIVE BARGAINING" for your beloved ALPA members when they have to GIVE BACK their COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT??
There is no "Give back" of a Collective Bargaining Agreement. Under the Railway Labor Act, the CBA remains in effect until amended or replaced. Nobody "gives back" a CBA. Many of our ALPA brothers have found themselves in the unfortunate situation of negotiating lower pay rates and inferior work rules, but the keyword remains the same - -negotiate.
Talk to us about the negotation that ocurred with your RJ payrates. Tell us how you're going to negotiate your next workrule change.
Pay attention here - - it's real simple.jbucpt said:so then what do call the actions taken by the american airline pilots, or what the delta pilots are going to do??? a "donation" to the company??
Here's what it's called...
Ready???
N E G O T I A T I O N
(HINT: Something a JBLU pilot can't do.)
Negatory, good buddy. The Railway Labor Act maintains that the CBA reamins in effect until amended or superceded.jbucpt said:a CBA guarantee's you nothing. it does not guarantee you wage protection, it does not guarantee you furlough protection, it does not guarantee you a pension plan.. so please stop with the ALPA KOOD-AID by stating that the jbu pilots are helpless without one.
ask a UNITED, USAIR , DELTA, TWA pilot how they feel about their "collective bargaining power"......
Pay - guaranteed
Furlough protection - depends on how the CBA is worded, but whatever is in the CBA is guaranteed
Pension plan - same as furlough - guaranteed
Before you get your panties in a wad, yes, you're right, if the Company goes bankrupt or out of business, then the CBA can't possibly guarantee ANYTHING - - pay, furlough, pension - - that SHOULD go without saying, but I'm sure you'll say it, so there's your answer already - - and in a run-on sentence at THAT! I ask you, though: how does that differ from an At-Will employee? Will an At-Will employee get any of those guarantees if the company goes under?
Now, before you accuse me of drinking ALPA KOOL-AID (Oh, the irony is thick here) go back and read my posts. Where did I say you were helpless without a CBA?
(HINT: Nowhere)
I did say that you are At-Will employees. The fact of the matter is, you're just a little bit better off than an At-Will employee since you have your Pilot Employment Contract. An At-Will employee could be termintated because he parted his hair on the wrong side, wore the wrong cologne, or for no reason at all - - as long as it doesn't violate those pesky Equal Employment guidelines, you know. At least you have some restrictions on THAT.
Now, as to what those pilots think about their CBA's? Well, I'll bet you a billion dollars that without their CBA's, Delta pilots would be making less than 60% of what they're making today. Without the CBA, hundreds more Delta pilots would be unemployed. Without the CBA's, all of those pilots you mentioned would be FAR worse off. All of those pilot groups have weathered terrible times at their companies, and their CBA's have helped them weather those times. I do not for a milisecond think they would be better off without their CBA's. The CBA's did not hurt the companies. The unions did not hurt the companies. The Economy, poor management strategies, and terrorism have hurt the companies.
Now, if you stop being so defensive and analyze what I've written, you'll realize I haven't bashed you or your contract. In fact, I think it's a bit generous in some respects. I answered some honest questions with straightforward answers - - that seems to be something you and many of your fellow crewmembers are hesitant to do. A Shakespeare quote comes to mind about protesteth(-ing) too much. (I hated that Shakespeare stuff - - seems to me he's WAY overrated, but that's another forum
Last edited: