Yeah, I work at ASA.
The relevant factors are:
- they can't do domestic feed as cheap as outsourced labor can.
- being able to whipsaw different airlines makes it even cheaper.
- they need bigger airplanes to take advantage of lower CASM and fuel efficiencies
They have to get the pilots to give up scope to make it work.
The way they could do it would be to offer an ultimatum:
Take a large pay increase to give up scope altogether and become widebody only pilots. The retirements and international growth would support that and leave everyone with a seat in a bigger airplane.
Or...
Get NOTHING and DAL spends the hundreds of millions to billions to fleet itself with RJs and pilots to bring it's domestic feed operation in-house.
I'm thinking that given the choice, the DAL group would vote itself a raise and a widebody seat over simply enlarging it's pilot group with newhires that are on the RJs.
Like I said, we'll see how it plays out.
If you were a DAL pilot and presented with those options, it would be completely stupid to pick option 2...it gets you NOTHING and costs an arm and a leg.
I think you are probably pretty close to stating WHAT WILL happen instead of talking about what pilots think SHOULD HAPPEN. I have seen quite a few posts about taking back scope, etc. but there is never even a hint in the discussion about what the pilots are willing to give up to achieve that goal. This leads me to believe that it is mostly empty talk and that you are closer to the reality of the industry. Nice post.