FDJ2 said:
Character, personality, knowledge, presentation, among other things are all part of the interview process, not just numbers on a resume. Experience isn't the only determining factor on getting the job. It would be quite easy to justify giving an applicant with less experience the job if that applicant was a better fit for the company and performed better in the interview and met the minimum requirements for the job, particularly since once the applicant gets the job he/she still has to successfully complete the training program.
There are plenty of highly experienced pilots who belong nowhere near a jet and there are plenty of less experienced pilots who could not only pass a checkride, but would make excellent captains one day.
By that ratioinale, how did United decide who they would call? They (Mrs. Stuke) claimed to have the most un-biased method for selecting who to interview. Fill out the scantron, fill out the app, mail it in. The only thing on the scantron is SSN and and flight times, everything else is on the the app, race, sex, ect. The scantron goes one way, the app goes another, at least according to them. The app is never even looked at until the computer spits out the SSN of the person's scantron it has selected, supposedly.
When deciding who to select for interview, go to the computer with the scantron info for the most "qualified" people to call. If UAL (and Mrs. Stuke) wanted to make a claim that they interviewed/hired only people with the best experience, there is no way in hell that ALOT of people would have even ever been called just to interview.
No where on the scantron did it have a bubble to fill out for character, knowledge, presentation, attitude, ect. And since the scantron was how they picked candidates, how did somebody with alot less experience get called while people with thousands of hours PIC, multiple type ratings, check airman expericence, never heard the phone ring?
With over 10,000 apps on file, I seriously doubt that they would have had to start lowering their competitve hours requirement just to find somebody with the right attitude.
Now I agree, attitude and personality go along way in the cockpit. I just don't believe they picked canidates solely on experience level.