If not FAA required then why do it? This is the problem with you guys; when someone makes a valid point you get all defensive and attack the person. I'm
hardly afraid of flying without the FD as I have been doing this for a long time. I mean according to your logic, we should shut down both engines because it could happen, right?
I would seriously question the judgement of a captain who continues to an airport on one engine with the weather at mins and no FD. But what do I know, I've only been flying transport cat airplanes for over 20 years!
FAA Doc. 8900.1 - Check Airman Handbook -VOL 5 Airman Certification ATP. Chapter 3 Sect 2 paragraph 5-832 APPROACH EVENTS. Sub-paragraph A. 2)
If the operator’s aircraft operating manual permits raw data ILS approaches to be conducted, the operator must provide training in the use of raw data for controlling an aircraft during ILS approaches. If the operator’s aircraft are equipped with a flight director system, the flight director must be used on at least one manually controlled ILS approach. While a raw data approach is not required to complete a flight test, inspectors and examiners should occasionally require a raw data approach to determine whether the operator’s training program is adequately preparing applicants.
When raw data is used on ILS or MLS approaches in an airplane, inspectors and examiners shall require applicants to use a DH of 200 feet above the touchdown zone.
To be fair to everyone, we don't discriminate. Everyone gets to do it. I would question having to fly with someone who was unable to do it and was too insecure in his or her own abilities to get it done. Its not always a matter of judgement, that may be your only choice. We train for the worst case scenario, not what actually happens day to day. If that were the case, we'd sit standby in the customer lounge and save on the sim expense.
Is that point valid enough for you? Do you feel attacked still? Those training guys are so out of control!!!! Help us IBT!!!! HELP US!!!!!
Last edited: