CRJ 200 climb performance in Summer

[RCA]

If your looking for climb rates go corporate. FL410 in 19 minutes is the norm in the "slowtation" Need to deviate around weather, climb @ 1000 FPM to FL450

 

[machaf]

Not that I would ever diverge from my company's published climb profile, but my all Skywest buddies tell me 250/.70m gets works a LOT better than 290/.70 to get to altitude. I think that was IDE's profile too, but I might be mistaken.

290/.70 works a LOT better when trying to go high. At 250/.70 you won't get above FL250 before the speed starts to drop.

AT 290 you can make it to FL300 right at 250kias, 50k lbs and fully loaded.

290kias until FL200 - then VS 500ft/min the rest of the way up.

 

[Poahi]

GCD,

Thanks for the comments. Are you saying that climbing out at a lower deck angle will give you greater range as well? In other words, if you were given barely enough fuel for the trip, would it be better to climb at 250, 290 or 310?

 

[gnx99]

If your looking for climb rates go corporate. FL410 in 19 minutes is the norm in the "slowtation" Need to deviate around weather, climb @ 1000 FPM to FL450

That's just like the Saab 340.

 

[machaf]

GCD,

Thanks for the comments. Are you saying that climbing out at a lower deck angle will give you greater range as well? In other words, if you were given barely enough fuel for the trip, would it be better to climb at 250, 290 or 310?

Climb at 250. Then reduce speed to long range cruise at altitude.

 

[Poahi]

Here's what I'm wondering. When it's hot and you're heavy, climbing out at 250 will get you to say FL200 in a hurry, but then the climb virtually stops and it seems like it takes forever to make it to cruise. At say, FL250, the deck angle is relatively high when you make the transition and I've had days where the aircraft never makes it cruise speed (desipte the charts saying otherwise). So what I'm curious about is whether or not the extra fuel burnt at lower altitides (and higher speed with lower deck angle), offsets 'hanging' at cruise at climb power for a half an hour. Does that extra 20 knots of initertia blast you through the doldrums or do you get it either way?

 

[DrewBlows]

OK, you can take it for what it's worth from a former CRJ instructor (one of the first in the USA), but it works very well.

Once you get to 10,000', nose it over to accelerate to 300-310 KIAS, then start climbing. As your altitude increases, try to maintain the highest possible IAS while maintaining at least a 500 FPM rate of climb. The idea is to climb a jet at the lowest possible deck angle to keep forward speed and increase economy. Also, when you get to your cruise altitude at the lower deck angle, you won't be "hanging" on the engines and unable to accelerate.

In the Whale, we use Vref + 100 to 110 for best angle of climb; Vref + 130-140 for best rate; Vref + 160-170 for best economy. It works as well in the CRJ, but not quite the same numbers, though.

Remember, the 500 FPM rule is only an ATC reporting requirement. A Part 25 jet is only required to be able to climb at cruise altitude at 300 FPM.

Please, please don't try to climb to your cruise altitude at best angle or best rate. You'll find that you likely will not get there because the best angle and best rate is a "temporary" rate for lower altitudes.

I have found that many who get into a jet for the first time have an unrealistic expectation of how a Transport Category Jet actually performs. Even the Whale peters out when it is heavy and hot. It's a rocket ship, even heavy, below FL180, but when we get on up there...it's 300 FPM sometimes.

Also, religiously check your cruise performance charts. Are you even legal to be where you are (FL wise)?

I learned from experience, if you use the climb techniue I described, you will beat the dispacthed fuel every time and you won't be pi**ing off guys behind you so badly.

Like I wrote, take it for what it's worth from an old dude.

That's interesting information. I've never flown the -200, but we used to climb at about 320/.80 in the CR7 (probably winter numbers, my memory isn't great) and it seemed to work well. The company came up with a 300/.77 profile and performance dies between about FL260 and FL300. They say do it that way, so I do, but we don't go as high as we used to and I suspect it costs us. On the other hand the descent profiles they gave us work pretty well (flight idle, cruise speed/290 KIAS).

The company profiles remind me of the profiles the company engineers gave Earnest K. Gahn's pilots in his book Fate is the Hunter. Everyone obeyed and barely made it to the destination until one brave soul used the old profiles and made it with plenty of fuel to spare.

 

[JettBoii]

I like big chi chi's. Nice avatar scang.

 

[Ganja60Heavy]

Man, it's bad. When I first started flying, I was like, whoa Captain, it's hard to keep this thing afloat! I think he knew what I meant, but I wanted to go faster so I dumped it over to about 200 per for a bit. Dude, it just wouldn't climb! Captain told me not to climb at that rate, but man, we gotta climb faster on hot days! How do you guys do it!?

Sounds like Captain is what's keeping you from crashin'....

 

[bertengineer]

There really is a reason the FMS displays

UNABLE CRZ ALT

 

[pilotdiscretion]

For some of you this is going to be the 'duh' statement of the year. For some of you this is going to be a wake up call.

Airplanes fly because of air flow over and under the wings.

Reduce the airflow and you reduce effectiveness of the wings. Keep the speed up between 280 and 310 and the airplane will keep climbing. It gets difficult and climbs very poorly between FL260 and FL280 due to atmospheric conditions and airplane design. Try to hold your speed between these altitudes and the airplane will perform better passing FL290.

Why do we let an ATC rule over ride aerodynamics? If the airplane needs to climb at 300 fpm why do we let the 500fpm notification rule put us in a position of high drag? ALPA should lobby to get this rule thrown out.

If you're departing a hub during a busy time please fly the company profile until you get some distance from the airport. When you get some distance from the departure corridor and are away from everyone else then you can slow down with out screwing the guys behind you.

 

[bluefishbeagle]

CRJ climb performance ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha........ etc infinity. It doesn't have any what's to talk about.

 

[SuperPilot]

CRJ 200 = Climb Restricted Jet 200fpm

 

[N1VIBS]

Why do we let an ATC rule over ride aerodynamics? If the airplane needs to climb at 300 fpm why do we let the 500fpm notification rule put us in a position of high drag? ALPA should lobby to get this rule thrown out.

I don't think its a ATC rule that you have to climb at 500 fpm. The rule( As I understand it)is if you can't climb at least 500 fpm, you have to notify ATC. Right GCD?

 

[Sawmill]

OK, you can take it for what it's worth from a former CRJ instructor (one of the first in the USA), but it works very well.

Once you get to 10,000', nose it over to accelerate to 300-310 KIAS, then start climbing. As your altitude increases, try to maintain the highest possible IAS while maintaining at least a 500 FPM rate of climb. The idea is to climb a jet at the lowest possible deck angle to keep forward speed and increase economy. Also, when you get to your cruise altitude at the lower deck angle, you won't be "hanging" on the engines and unable to accelerate.

In the Whale, we use Vref + 100 to 110 for best angle of climb; Vref + 130-140 for best rate; Vref + 160-170 for best economy. It works as well in the CRJ, but not quite the same numbers, though.

Remember, the 500 FPM rule is only an ATC reporting requirement. A Part 25 jet is only required to be able to climb at cruise altitude at 300 FPM.

Please, please don't try to climb to your cruise altitude at best angle or best rate. You'll find that you likely will not get there because the best angle and best rate is a "temporary" rate for lower altitudes.

I have found that many who get into a jet for the first time have an unrealistic expectation of how a Transport Category Jet actually performs. Even the Whale peters out when it is heavy and hot. It's a rocket ship, even heavy, below FL180, but when we get on up there...it's 300 FPM sometimes.

Also, religiously check your cruise performance charts. Are you even legal to be where you are (FL wise)?

I learned from experience, if you use the climb techniue I described, you will beat the dispacthed fuel every time and you won't be pi**ing off guys behind you so badly.

Like I wrote, take it for what it's worth from an old dude.

Its refreshing to hear from someone who actually knows what they are talking about and not just wanting to "hear" themselves.