1. Not flying overtime has not helped UPS in the pace or effectiveness of their negotiations, why would it help us?
UPS, a year ahead of us in contract negotiations, has not flown draft since management announced that they would furlough 50 pilots about three years ago. I don't see their negotiations benefiting from this decision in either pace or effectiveness.
Why?
UPS, like FedEx, has an amazing amount of slop in their system. Look at your loads next time you fly. If a flight to SYR cancells for lack of pilots, the ROC flight has plenty of room....and that crew then gets the pleasure of being involuntarily assigned an additional leg, after showtime, thereby cutting their crewrest from 12 hours to 9. Think about it ...there are probably 10 or more flights to the LA basin ever day....and they are not all full...you can lose one or more and still not lose any revenue. We have tons of reserve, airport standbys, sweep flights, hotel standbys and half full planes that can be re-routed.
2. The union has not taken a position on this matter.
As I see it there are only two reasons. First, it could be interpreted as an illegal job action. Or second, it is not helpful to our negotiations at this time.
3. The union speaks clearlY.
They don't want us to fly disputed pairings....that could not be more clear. The union has said to fly the contract...we fly the contract.
I CHALLANGE ANYONE TO PROVIDE CONCRETE UNION GUIDANCE SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSING OVERTIME FLYING.
4. To stop flying overtime now will take away a negotiating tool when it is legal and most effective.
If we implement a word of mouth campaign slowly and haphazardly to stop extra flying, the company will time to effectively modify its manning or schedules to cope with the change.
A better alternative is, once released into self help, for the union to take an offical position to stop overtime and implement it on a specific day. The more dependant the company is on overtime flying now the more effective it will be for us when it is legal to take away later.
5. Let cool heads and logic prevail.
As far as I am aware, the company has not engaged in any illegal job actions. They have not fired pilots indiscrimenately, failed union leaders on their annual checkrides or taken any other actions barred by the RLA.
Every email I have recived about negotiations from our union point to coninuing, yet slow, progress.
We as union members have an equally important requirement to both follow the law and our union leadership.
This is a long frustrating process, avoid the temptation to take action from "side" groups or "rouge" attempts to influence negotionations. Don't let your emotions make you an easy target by advocating an illegal job action that will potentially put your job and career in jeapordy.
I am sure this will generate a lot of "emotional" personal attacks about greed....but please look above and see that every logical argument raised is not about money or personal gain....its about whats best for us as a whole.