They did...mostly because of the personality of Jim Parker, the CEO at the time (2004-ish)...Herb came back to the negotiating table and gave them what they wanted and then Parker later left as CEO after only a year or 2 on the job to "spend more time with his family". It does not matter...this TA will pass 2 to 1 no matter what it says. Pilots are easy prey for any airline manager and SWA is no exception.