You're already wrong. The pinnacle dooshers weren't up in arms at all. I remember one guy remarking on "how lean the company will be after the new concessionary contract" to gain more flying. What a bunch of turds.
After the carrot was dangled, you are right. Before the carrot (where xjet is) everyone wanted to shut er down. Much like the general saying no more 76 seaters before their carrot was dangled. It's easy to say no way when there is nothing being dangled in front of you.