Hudson Ditching Left Engine Running at 35%

[grog_sit_reserv]

Shouldn't this be on the Flight Instructor Forum?

 

[ron burgundy]

Very interesting update. Makes you wonder if something may have been botched.

I agree! Somebody Botched ...Your mothers attempted abortion.

Lucky us!

 

[Thebadcat1313]

The fan blades were certainly badly damaged by the ingested bird(s). Just because it was running at 35% doesn't mean it was producing the thrust you would expect at that RPM, only that there was enough rotation to drive hydraulics and the generator. It could very well have not been producing thrust at all. Probably only slightly better than a windmilling engine.

 

[Diesel-9]

Sully made the right choice. LGA/TEB were very risky alternatives for different reasons. Its one thing to discuss the results and options they had. But to second guess Sully and what he did is sad. People who do that probably need progressive taxi instructions on a daily basis. The only question I had as Sully made the second pass through the cabin was, "Did he get all the Merlot of the ship?"

 

[Amish RakeFight]

He absolutely made the right decision, given the circumstances. Perhaps he may have made it back to LGA, TEB, EWR, etc. But that would have been based on pure probability on that fateful day. The potential for a successful landing at any airport would be highly questionable. There were too many variables involved to have taken a chance on getting it to a hard-surfaced runway. Too many variables to consider. (obstacles, glide, lining up, system failures, etc.). Too many "what if's" to contend with. A water ditching in the Hudson river presented the crew with better known variables to work with and control. K.I.S.S. This is an essential point and why the decison to ditch vs. making an attempt at an airport, seemed more prudent and rightly so.

 

[Amish RakeFight]

Talk of attempting to glide (a questionable aircraft) into an airport with a river and formal ditching procedures available is foolish. Seriously.

 

[landlover]

Um, ever hear of breakaway thrust? Or is that just something jet pilots know about!LOL

i hope your husband beats you because you deserve it.

 

[Simon Says]

i hope your husband beats you because you deserve it.

We went over this on another thread.....POKE MY PE_N_I$ is a dude. That is what is so funny about his avatar.

Can you say Gay Pilot Ass.

 

[SpauldingSmails]

Yeah I think it's a lot harder to come up short on the river then to come up short on EWR or TEB...

if this guy banged through the approach lights and smeared everyone a quarter inch thick and an eighth mile long these are the same a-holes who would have said he should have put it in the river.

Everyone lived. Enough said.

 

[ableone]

If the autoflight system was disengaged and the nose lowered and the airplane was at its 210 target speed the autothrust system would have commanded idle thrust.

I am interested to see if the autothrust system was ever disengaged and the thrust lever moved forward.

The investigation also shows that the final re-start occurred at 500 ft and 200kias. Unless APU bleed was selected on this would not be successful.

 

[30West]

If only all of this bait was as effective on Marlin or Swordfish as it is on pilots.......

 

[C-150ETOPS]

I did try what happened to Sully in the Sim and at home on the computer and I made it!! It wasn't pretty but I made it.

Another FI classic.

Just a friendly observation. Renting a Jenna Jameson DVD is not the same as having the talent to make her see stars and rip the sheets with her fingernails, no matter how good you feel when the credits roll.

Now if someone was pointing a loaded Glock at your head the first time you tried the MS Sim scenario, and knowing the trigger gets pulled if you screwed the deadstick, that might be a more valid test. Would be fun to watch on a webcam too.:laugh:

 

[CA1900]

Just a friendly observation. Renting a Jenna Jameson DVD is not the same as having the talent to make her see stars and rip the sheets with her fingernails, no matter how good you feel when the credits roll.

Hahahahahaha....

Comedy gold! :laugh:

 

[airplane wizard]

A high bypass engine make all its thrust in the last 20% N1. 35 % would not even get the thing taxiing on one engine. He was smart to leave it running for hydraulics. And less flaps on landing was smart also!! he did a great job for only having 3 minutes!!

Why was less flaps better?

 

[av8trinabarrel]

Isn't it interesting how "Brown-on-his-bone", "Instructor-Doosh", and "Poke-her-hole Pylit" all post back-to-back...........

Who needs the frickn comedy channel when you have the 3 amigos hosting their own battle of the biggest maroon's on the planet!

Keep the good times flown ladies.....imp: