Initial open time or future open time? There is a difference, after all.
The difference here would be what? FWIW, this is the only area where I could personally see a small amount of give and take. If you are looking in IOT to replace time dropped for a vacation or perhaps some sort of other training event, just to get your line back to the minimum line value, I could see that as potentially justifiable. To pick up open time so that you can increase your earnings above the minimum guarantee is still keeping a furloughed pilot out on the street.
One thing to consider is that the staffing projections look historically at how many crews it takes to cover a given amount of flying. That includes historical levels of picking up open time, sick calls, etc.
So, the company decides how many to furlough based on that staffing model. They then furlough the 80 people, but now no one picks up open time (in your perfect world), so the staffing model is incorrect. So now line pilots get extended more frequently, and get paid more money to fly time and a half when it could have cost the company just straight time.
Nah, my world's not perfect. But, neither is your logic, here, either.
If the staffing model is not correct, I would expect the company to do the most cost effective thing to remedy that situation. If it really costs the company more to extend pilots (doubtful, but possible), the correct, logical thing to do would be to bring some, or all, of the furloughed pilots back.
The fact is that the staffing model is set, and picking up open time or not is certainly not going to lose or save anyone's jobs. It is purely in your head that you are making a difference.
My head, and my conscience, tells me that it's wrong to undertake an action for my own personal gain, as in pick up open time, that harms my fellow man (pilot). Clearly, your head, and conscience, tells you otherwise. As respectfully as possible, I would suggest that we will have to disagree on this issue.
I understand the sentiment, and it certainly is not a good situation we have going here, but monkeying around with the system will only make things worse.
Don't misunderstand me: I'm not suggesting in any way that any person undertake any action that will harm the company. I would take an extremely dim view of someone intentionally undertaking an action that would harm our performance in the eyes of our customers, be they the people in the back, or, the folks in the Kremlin.
Besides, if you think anyone is REALLY going to show any solidarity and not pick up open time, you are smoking something. When it is all said and done, people are going to do what they have to do for their families. That has been shown time and again in this industry.