Fact: There is nobody worse than Tilton. If you believe the hype, there's nobody better than Kellner. Peal back a few layers and both companies ain't doing too great. Scale out all factors and I think it's too close to call as to what pilot group is better off long term.
CAL's A plan is going to get leveraged against our scope clause IMHO. That's why the funding isn't solvent. The CALALPA tool bags put a bullseye on the pilot plan when the divided it from the company wide CARP. Larry put the early ret. window out there and more should have taken it. But honestly, if he doubled the amount he would not have doubled the participation. And he knows that; That was a calculated number. He knows he has a whole bunch of stupid-acting, senior CAL guys who will keep showing up no matter. Larry doesn't know for certain if he will win or lose the showdown over CAL scope vs. CAL A plan. Having put the early out dollars on the table, if he losses on scope and the A plan gets scuttled, he can say he tried to help them. They were too stupid to go.
Pension concerns at CAL need to be a distant second to preserving the scope clause.