I agree 100%, an ATP says that you have at least 1500 hrs but I am sure JT has more than double that and since he reportedly flies allot of hard IMC, I would give the nod to a private pilot with 1500+ hrs of instrument filing time with half that in the soup or under the hood. I don't think JT is lacking in the "experience" department so, IMO, he has all the ratings and licenses he'll ever need.
Some of the best pilots in the world don't hold anything more than a private.
I agree that experience is the most important thing when assessing potential pilot abilties, next to that, I think being a high time instrument pilot with allot of actual beats the hell out of a "low time" ATP that lets George fly everyday. If most of JT's hours are single pilot IFR, he has to envy noone, not that he would anyway.
If I were JT and flying heavys, I would do the ATPjust because it's there to do. In fact, I am doing it, not because I need to but because it's another rating I can learn from. Being a physician, I have to do it twice as good as the next guy because of all the stereotypes. I became a doctor so I could afford to fly, that should tell you how much I like flying. When you quit learning, you start dying, in aviation or anything else!
Oh and BTW, I am retiring in 5 years to fly charter in the Bahamas and give up playing doctor because I can and want to, sound crazy??????
