Planes were circling each other at time of collision
By LARRY SANDLER and TOM HELD
Posted: Feb. 6, 2006
Juneau - The two cargo planes that collided near Watertown were circling and taking pictures of each other on a final shakedown flight before a scheduled Monday departure for service in Iraq, a federal transportation official said.
Its landing gear apparently disabled by the midair collision, this Air Cargo Carriers plane limped to the Dodge County Airport and landed on its belly.
The Shorts 360 planes, owned by Milwaukee-based Air Cargo Carriers Inc., had been fitted recently with extended-range fuel systems for the work in Iraq, said Todd Fox, a National Transportation Safety Board investigator. Their pending mission in Iraq was part of a contract with the U.S. Defense Department.
The planes left Mitchell International Airport around 4 p.m. Sunday. The flights were intended as a final check of those systems and a picture-taking opportunity.
Before the crash, the crews had been taking still and video pictures as one of the planes circled the other, Fox told reporters at the Dodge County Airport in Juneau. Fox said he did not know how the company had planned to use the pictures.
As one of the planes circled, it collided with the other plane.
The circling craft was disabled and crashed, killing Robert Chabot, 25, of Plano, Texas; Todd Hagan, 42, of Essex Junction, Vt.; and his wife, Tracy Marshall Hagan, 37.
Chabot had worked for Air Cargo Carriers for about three years, according to his sister, Elizabeth Chabot.
After the collision, the other damaged plane limped roughly 20 miles to the Dodge County Airport. With its landing gear apparently disabled by the crash, the plane skidded onto a runway there on its belly around 5:30 p.m. All three people on board survived without injury, authorities said.
The left wing was heavily damaged, Fox said, but he declined to comment on whether that was the spot hit by the other aircraft.
Dodge County Sheriff Todd Nehls identified the survivors as Andrew Lambert, 26, of Chesapeake, Va.; Timothy Vanderploeg, 23, of Allegan, Mich.; and Rudy Nikolao, 52, of Kingston, Va.
Fox said the pilots, co-pilots and passengers had expected to be airborne for up to two hours.
The pictures taken by the surviving air crew now will become evidence in the NTSB investigation, along with Federal Aviation Administration radar data, statements from the survivors and the two aircraft themselves, Fox said. It could take weeks or months to determine the cause of the accident.