Before this thread degenerates further into a military vs. civilian thing, may I humbly suggest that those of you so inclined use the search function, that topic has been "done" ad nauseum, many times before. If you are a civilian or military guy who thinks your stuff doesn't stink because you:
- Got stood up for a year
- Flew freight by yourself in broken old airplanes in all kinds of weather
- Can execute a perfect echelon turn in your T-38 without even thinking
- Fly everyday in and out of the world's busiest airspace
...then here's a newsflash for you:
you haven't been in the cockpit very long and/or your head is buried up your fat SNAP behind. Nobody cares but you. The rest of us have more important things to think about and do. To that end, I'm going to attempt to start a conversation here that may return this thread to something useful and educational.
Overrun accidents occur regularly in both civilian and military aircraft. They should be preventable, but aviators have yet to devise a system or training solution to greatly reduce their numbers. The importance of stabilized approaches are beat into our collective heads, and the critical nature of SOP's are hammered by IP's, Simuflite, Stan Eval, Check Airmen, you name it.
So where's the disconnect? I believe part of the problem is in situations where we really need the structure of carefully regulated callouts and stabilized approach parameters, they're the first thing that gets thrown out the window. (SWA in BUR comes to mind. SW has several altitude gates associated with their approaches for velocity and configuration, along with a callout. The crew was so busy trying to 'make it work' that they missed the callouts.) On a sunny calm day or in the simulator when your mentally primed for it, making a decision to abandon the approach is pretty easy. You've got lot's of un-used brain cells and SA to spare. Throw in rapidly deteriorating conditions, get-home-itis, fatigue and other variables, and it becomes difficult to see the need to go-around, and even more challenging to speak up and say it. (Many of us pride ourselves on being hard-wired for that kind of thing, but truth is, few of us are.)
I don't want to make this post so long nobody reads it, so let me invite others to post their views of why overruns continue to occur with pretty alarming regularity. After a few more we can discuss solutions, techniques and ideas.
Anybody?