Bake:
Perhaps no one would need this relief if you guys didn't go to work with an inadequate retirement in the first place?
Tell you what I'm doing. I'm getting myself ready no matter what. Some may remember, you obviously don't, my father was an airline pilot and lost his entire, fully funded retirement plan around 50 yrs old. This business can get ugly quick no matter who you are; We got through it with some hard work and we didn't get to plan for it. You SWA guys sound so freakin desperate theres no way you could get through what my family did. A lot of you guys have worked there 20+ years, you now act completely ambushed! It's sad, most successful airline can't retire pilots comfortably. (or so you would have us all believe) Another thing I'm doing is towing the line. ALPA doesn't want it changed. I also support protecting the lump sum option at CAL. Recent legislation change efforts just about doused that for us and it's a big deal. Guys with around 25 yrs leave here with about 700k. (some as much as 900k)
I'm familiar with many of the Braniff types at SWA. They've got 20 or so years and most could get out OK. Frankly, it surprises me that they have not done better on the stock, right? It's really a mystery to me but I'm told it's not all it's cracked up to be. Bottom line, they can retire and get by OK, but they want the extra five cause it's all gravy at this point. It's the easiest money they'll ever make really.
Bottom line, we should not feed that greed imperative. We don't need to re-amortize the careers of everyone else for the lopsided benefit of a few. Where an FO might forego 300k in earnings for the five extra years, a CA makes around 3 times that amount in the same five years! The FO that took the hit won't get that back at all unless they also work past 60.
You SWA guys should keep working on a "local" solution to your problem. Expand the use of your sick leave for medical benefits age 60+. Start your own fund somehow, put a jar on every ticket counter maybe. Tell each of your customers how tough it is to be a SWA pilot post age 60, see if they want to throw in a few extra bucks. My guess is they'll tell you a story about the $8 ticket they bought to KSAT and ask you to share the wisdom in that with regard to your current retirement dilemna.