Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Some passengers fail to realize they are not flying mainline

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

General Lee

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2002
Posts
20,442
Airline Passengers Fail to Realize Some Trips Flown by Partners

By John Hughes--Bloomberg - Oct 26, 2010

U.S. airline passengers buy tickets from carriers such as Continental Airlines without realizing their flight may be aboard regional partners that are being scrutinized for safety practices, a safety board was told.

A document confirming a flight for Elly Kausner, who died when a regional carrier’s plane crashed near Buffalo, New York, last year, thanked her for flying Continental, her father, John, said at a National Transportation Safety Board hearing today.

The document “says nothing about Colgan Air,” the unit of Pinnacle Airlines Corp. that flew the fatal fight on behalf of Continental, John Kausner said.

Kausner was among the witnesses as the NTSB examines the business relationships between airlines and their smaller partners, and what the airlines and federal regulators are doing to ensure all types of airlines are held to safety standards.

“This myriad of relationships can be confusing to the traveling public,” NTSB Chairman Deborah Hersman said on the first day of hearings. “We need to know more, and the public needs to know more.”

Passengers may check in at an airport ticket counter run by Delta Air Lines Inc. or United Continental Holdings Inc. and see those carriers’ names painted on planes, only to realize later the flights are made by Comair or Air Wisconsin Airlines Corp., Hersman said.

Safety practices at regional carriers, which account for about half of all scheduled U.S. passenger flights, have been under scrutiny by the Federal Aviation Administration, Congress and the NTSB following the Colgan crash that killed 50 people.

Six Fatal Crashes

The carriers have been involved in the last six commercial airline accidents with fatalities on board, the Transportation Department’s inspector general, Calvin Scovel, said in testimony in June 2009.

Regional carriers and their partners must meet identical safety regulations and there “absolutely” is one level of safety in the industry, Roger Cohen, president of the Regional Airline Association, a Washington trade group for the small airlines, told the NTSB.

“Safety is the No. 1 concern,” Cohen said. It would be “crummy business” for any airline to do anything to compromise safety.

Kevin Mitchell, chairman of the Business Travel Coalition, presented survey results today showing two-thirds of corporate travel managers report fliers saying safety differences exist between large airlines and smaller partners.

About eight in 10 of those fliers avoid turboprop aircraft, according to Mitchell, whose group is based in Radnor, Pennsylvania. He said he surveyed 212 travel managers, agents and other professionals from Oct. 14 through Oct. 22.

‘Much Higher Airfares’

“A majority of corporations indicate that they would be willing to pay much higher airfares in return for higher safety standards at the regional airlines,” Mitchell said in his survey findings.

Airlines should be responsible for ensuring that pilots at their regional partners meet all the same experience and training requirements of the big carrier, Kausner told the board.

The two pilots who flew the Colgan plane to Buffalo “could not have flown for Continental, they weren’t qualified,” he said at a news conference with about 25 relatives of people who died in the crash.

The NTSB said in February that Captain Marvin Renslow of Colgan caused his plane to crash by incorrectly responding to a cockpit stall warning. Everyone aboard the plane died, along with one person on the ground.





If the government ever ties Mainline and Regionals together for litigation reasons (since people who died thought beforehand they were flying Mainline) it will be the end of Regionals probably. Any Regional crashes would result in huge awards against Mainline Airline insurance companies, and therefore insurance will become too expensive to operate a Regional. This Colgan crash has really done a lot to expose some major problems with fatigue and rest, but also some loopholes for airline management.

Regardless though, YOU GUYS ARE ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC. REALLY. I LOVE YOU GUYS. And, if you have time tonight or early tomorrow, do something nice for someone or something, like allowing mice to ride Frosted Mini Wheats down a small stream or river. That sounds like a lot of fun for them! See ya!


Bye Bye--General Lee
 
Last edited:
Your hypothesis about running regional out of business by tying them to mainline carriers is based on nothing more than your own wishes. I can't think of a regional that was put out of business from an accident, as a matter of fact, I can't think of a regional that has lost any significant money because of a crash. Mainline is already paying regional insurance premiums in the by default since regional collect all of their revenue from their mainline "partners."
 
>>>If the government ever ties Mainline and Regionals together for litigation reasons (since people who died thought beforehand they were flying Mainline) it will be the end of Regionals probably. Any Regional crashes would result in huge awards against Mainline Airline insurance companies, and therefore insurance will become too expensive to operate a Regional. This Colgan crash has really done a lot to expose some major problems with fatigue and rest, but also some loopholes for airline management.

Regardless though, YOU GUYS ARE ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC. REALLY. I LOVE YOU GUYS. And, if you have time tonight or early tomorrow, do something nice for someone or something, like allowing mice to ride Frosted Mini Wheats down a small stream or river. That sounds like a lot of fun for them! See ya!


Bye Bye--General Lee>>>

Drinking and posting again, or just something else?
 
he's back to his ways! but forgot to mention DAL overflying msp, landing on twys in atl etc etc

can I get a wind ck here amen :laugh:
 
If the government ever ties Mainline and Regionals together for litigation reasons (since people who died thought beforehand they were flying Mainline) it will be the end of Regionals probably. Any Regional crashes would result in huge awards against Mainline Airline insurance companies, and therefore insurance will become too expensive to operate a Regional. This Colgan crash has really done a lot to expose some major problems with fatigue and rest, but also some loopholes for airline management.

It can't happen soon enough! Go Gen'ruhl, go!
 
Unfortunately, it wouldn't have made a difference. If all 50 people knew they were flying on Colgan Air, and knew it's pay model, work rules, etc, they would have still boarded the flight. What else would they do?

Can't help thinking about the jumpseater on the flight. If I remember correctly, there was one in the back. There's a chance that had there been one more pax and he had to sit up front, this could have been avoided.

R/ Maui Jim
 
Last edited:
Your hypothesis about running regional out of business by tying them to mainline carriers is based on nothing more than your own wishes. I can't think of a regional that was put out of business from an accident, as a matter of fact, I can't think of a regional that has lost any significant money because of a crash. Mainline is already paying regional insurance premiums in the by default since regional collect all of their revenue from their mainline "partners."

I guess Colgan rushing into a merger and trying to dump the Colgan name had NOTHING to do with the crash........or any future litigation? And if Mainline does pay for an Umbrella policy for the Regionals (????), higher premiums wouldn't make the Mainline carriers think twice? Riiight?

I brought this up because I think it could be an issue in the future, not to make you guys all nervous, which is what has happened. It is obvious you are scared, and that is sad. BUT, YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME REGARDLESS.

HAVE A GREAT DAY, BUDS.


Bye Bye--General Lee
 
I guess Colgan rushing into a merger and trying to dump the Colgan name had NOTHING to do with the crash........or any future litigation? And if Mainline does pay for an Umbrella policy for the Regionals (????), higher premiums wouldn't make the Mainline carriers think twice? Riiight?

I brought this up because I think it could be an issue in the future, not to make you guys all nervous, which is what has happened. It is obvious you are scared, and that is sad. BUT, YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME REGARDLESS.

HAVE A GREAT DAY, BUDS.


Bye Bye--General Lee

General Lee, tell your FAs to stop smiling, their smilling everyone to death. How about some actual service? people are paying 500 bucks a ticket. You're 767 is no different than an RJ ride for the passengers, at least on an rj your not stuck as long.
 
Last edited:
Airline Passengers Fail to Realize Some Trips Flown by Partners

By John Hughes--Bloomberg - Oct 26, 2010

U.S. airline passengers buy tickets from carriers such as Continental Airlines without realizing their flight may be aboard regional partners that are being scrutinized for safety practices, a safety board was told.

A document confirming a flight for Elly Kausner, who died when a regional carrier’s plane crashed near Buffalo, New York, last year, thanked her for flying Continental, her father, John, said at a National Transportation Safety Board hearing today.

The document “says nothing about Colgan Air,” the unit of Pinnacle Airlines Corp. that flew the fatal fight on behalf of Continental, John Kausner said.

Kausner was among the witnesses as the NTSB examines the business relationships between airlines and their smaller partners, and what the airlines and federal regulators are doing to ensure all types of airlines are held to safety standards.

“This myriad of relationships can be confusing to the traveling public,” NTSB Chairman Deborah Hersman said on the first day of hearings. “We need to know more, and the public needs to know more.”

Passengers may check in at an airport ticket counter run by Delta Air Lines Inc. or United Continental Holdings Inc. and see those carriers’ names painted on planes, only to realize later the flights are made by Comair or Air Wisconsin Airlines Corp., Hersman said.

Safety practices at regional carriers, which account for about half of all scheduled U.S. passenger flights, have been under scrutiny by the Federal Aviation Administration, Congress and the NTSB following the Colgan crash that killed 50 people.

Six Fatal Crashes

The carriers have been involved in the last six commercial airline accidents with fatalities on board, the Transportation Department’s inspector general, Calvin Scovel, said in testimony in June 2009.

Regional carriers and their partners must meet identical safety regulations and there “absolutely” is one level of safety in the industry, Roger Cohen, president of the Regional Airline Association, a Washington trade group for the small airlines, told the NTSB.

“Safety is the No. 1 concern,” Cohen said. It would be “crummy business” for any airline to do anything to compromise safety.

Kevin Mitchell, chairman of the Business Travel Coalition, presented survey results today showing two-thirds of corporate travel managers report fliers saying safety differences exist between large airlines and smaller partners.

About eight in 10 of those fliers avoid turboprop aircraft, according to Mitchell, whose group is based in Radnor, Pennsylvania. He said he surveyed 212 travel managers, agents and other professionals from Oct. 14 through Oct. 22.

‘Much Higher Airfares’

“A majority of corporations indicate that they would be willing to pay much higher airfares in return for higher safety standards at the regional airlines,” Mitchell said in his survey findings.

Airlines should be responsible for ensuring that pilots at their regional partners meet all the same experience and training requirements of the big carrier, Kausner told the board.

The two pilots who flew the Colgan plane to Buffalo “could not have flown for Continental, they weren’t qualified,” he said at a news conference with about 25 relatives of people who died in the crash.

The NTSB said in February that Captain Marvin Renslow of Colgan caused his plane to crash by incorrectly responding to a cockpit stall warning. Everyone aboard the plane died, along with one person on the ground.





If the government ever ties Mainline and Regionals together for litigation reasons (since people who died thought beforehand they were flying Mainline) it will be the end of Regionals probably. Any Regional crashes would result in huge awards against Mainline Airline insurance companies, and therefore insurance will become too expensive to operate a Regional. This Colgan crash has really done a lot to expose some major problems with fatigue and rest, but also some loopholes for airline management.

Regardless though, YOU GUYS ARE ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC. REALLY. I LOVE YOU GUYS. And, if you have time tonight or early tomorrow, do something nice for someone or something, like allowing mice to ride Frosted Mini Wheats down a small stream or river. That sounds like a lot of fun for them! See ya!


Bye Bye--General Lee

Aviation geek
 
“This myriad of relationships can be confusing to the traveling public,” NTSB Chairman Deborah Hersman said on the first day of hearings. “We need to know more, and the public needs to know more.”

Really?

Every ticket, e-ticket or otherwise shows the name of the regional carrier who is operating the flight. This practice has been going on for decades and is a choice made by every network carrier. Is Chairman Hersman suggesting the passenger has the presence of mind to pull out a credit card, enter 16 digits but fails to read on the confirmation that the flight was operated by another carrier? Really?

".... we need to know more..."? Really? Does Chairman Hersman not know the relationship between regionals and mainline parters? Is that "myriad" too confusing for her? That should frighten the public.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top