Snakum said:
It is the right of every American to kill themselves in whatever manner they see fit.
That sounds great, but it's not exactly true.
First, there are laws that prohibit many manners of death.
Second, inasmuch as some behaviors cost society as a whole, society has a right to voice an objection. Off the top of my head I can see two ways that smoking costs society as a whole. First, the burden imposed on the government in dealing with the results of smoking is passed on to the taxpayer -- US. (I'm not happy with that arrangement, but that's another subject.) Second, the burden imposed on insurance underwriters is passed on to the policy holders that pay increased premiums or enjoy reduced benefits.
So, while it is legal for a non-minor to kill himself by smoking, it is not a right. As with any such issue, the will of the majority may be imposed on all through legislation that might restrict or prohibit smoking.
Snakum said:
If they wanna smoke ... have at it. I don't care, as long as they're considerate of the smell and the butts. I smoke sometimes, but not regularly, and I always try to wash up and hit some chewing gum afterward, and I am very conscious of what I do with the left-overs (I field-strip them and throw the filter in the trash).
I appreciate your consideration. I imagine that if all smokers were as considerate as you, this thread would not exist. Apparently, the originator of this thread was disgruntled not so much by the fact that some people smoke as he was that a particular smoker had been quite INconsiderate in leaving the hotel room in a stinky mess. (Reference the closing words of his fourth point.)
I think we'd all be happy if smokers were just considerate, as you claim to be, of non-smokers. (OK, well, MOST of us would be happy with that, some folks refuse to be happy.) That seems to be all the poster really wants.
Snakum said:
You guys on the soapbox remind me of the do-gooders who gave us helmet laws.
The arguments to "the right of every American to kill themselves in whatever manner they see fit" apply the same.