Wow - this thread has gone a completely new direction since I last checked in!
Over the years, I've met lots of different people in aviation. It's always a goal of mine to meet someone new every time I head out to the airport. It seems to me that the vast majority of pilots out there have a strong desire to fly on some level. I've only met a few that regard it as a hobby on the same level that say, golf, is a hobby. But what I've also found is that the reasons behind the desire vary a bit in different people.
I think these varying reasons behind the desire is why there's a difference in opinion here. And really, I don't necessarily think one is any more valid than the other. Both result in a pilot that wants to learn as much as possible and be as proficient as possible - even if the underlying motivations are a little different.
When people ask me why I fly, the primary reason I give is simply the feeling of freedom I have when I'm up there. Not freemdom in the CFR/TFR/etc sense, but just the idea that regardless of whatever is going on in my life on the ground, be it stresses with school, relationships, my job, or whatever else - it gets left on the ground. In the time that I'm up there, it's just me, the plane, and the sky around me. Everything else disappears. Problems on the ground are tiny and insignificant. I can be flying over the most crime ridden ghetto area of the city, and from a mile up - it's no different than the middle class suburbs 10 miles away. I'm happy. I'm up there doing what I love to do, and every stress in the world can wait until I'm driving home from the airport.
Secondary to the above is the challenge of it all. My grandfather always told me that at any given time in the cockpit, if I can't think of 3 things I could be doing better - I'm not working hard enough. There's a satisfaction that comes from always striving to be perfect. I'll never accomplish it, of course, but I love the fact that no matter how proficient I get as a pilot - there's always another milestone to get to, and I can always raise the bar a little higher. Simply, there's always more to learn - and that's awesome!
Now, there are many, many other smaller reasons that I fly, but the two above are my primary ones, or at least the tangible ones that can be described with words.
Okay, so what's my point? Well, I'll bet that FlyChicaga identifies more with my second reason than the first one. He loves the challenge...and this drives him to always be looking at the bigger, faster plane. Or maybe older, in the DC-3 case. I'm sure that plane has a completely different set of challenges all its own! I personally am just as happy overall putzing around in a 152 as I am the Duchess. FlyChicaga probably doesn't feel the same way. But I also love the feeling of being 'in the system' when IFR, or the pleasure of initially feeling like I was way behind the plane when first learning to fly the Duchess, yet now it fits like an old glove. So I can see his point as view as well.
But fundamentally, we have the same passion. And although the reasons behind that passion may be different, it ultimately makes us strive to be the best pilots we're capable of being. And at least in my mind, that's the important thing.
Or I can be completely full of sh*t, and have FlyChicaga all wrong. But it's how I see it. I see young punks that really have no clue how good they have it, and others that have the passion but are merely well financed. I get jealous about it too, but I try hard not to equate the money with the calibur of pilot.
I also see old guys that have piss poor attitudes as well. My grandfather flew P-38's, and my life goal is to fly one before I die. I realize it's a VERY long shot, but I'm going to give it a try. I told this to a current P-38 pilot while admiring one at a museum, and he simply said, "Give it up, kid. There's no way you have the talent to fly one of these things. None of you young guys do." I'll never forget his words. That was just over a year ago, and my eyes still glass over when I think of that guy telling me that.
Okay...I'm done rambling! Thank you for your time.
