Stearmandriver
Well-known member
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2003
- Posts
- 249
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AcroChik said:If you want even-handedness and rational discussion, in which each assertion is carefully substantiated, try the political threads here.
AcroChik said:If you want even-handedness and rational discussion, in which each assertion is carefully substantiated, try the political threads here.
You have good vocabulary skills. I'm sure if you keep looking you'll find the "engaged" switch for your sense of humor![]()
ERJ-140 said:I think it is clear that calling the Legacy a piece of sh-- is unfair, just as comparing a Legacy to a G350 is unfair.
ERJ-140 said:No airplane is perfect, not even the mighty G550.
ERJ-140 said:... B&CA seems to support the bulk of LegacyDude's numbers regarding the Legacy's performance, not the numbers shown by GVFlyer) it is informative to some degree. I have learned more about Gulfstreams than I ever thought possible.
The brakes...GVFlyer said:What do you feel to be wrong with the G550?
Why am I kidding? I'm not referring to their overall stopping power... I'm referring to what AA717 said...Ace-of-the-Base said:You've GOT to be kidding.
Ace
AcroChik said:Speaking of the WSCoD he writes (and I quote with relish), "It is a fragile collection of expedients."
Coming from a man who never responds to wanton lunacy or taunts with vitriol, whose default is rationality and to dig for and analyze data, the above line is as defining as the nom de farce by which this pilloried airframe in now globally known. And I'm still laughing.
Much of the certification for the ERJ-135, upon which the Legacy is based, was conducted from our ramp. The same FAA Test Pilots from the Atlanta ACO that worked on GV cert performed the same function for the ERJ-135, as such I have fairly extensive knowledge of the Embraer and it's shortcomings. It is a fragile collection of expedients.
ERJ-140 said:...From what I am gathering here you have never flown the Legacy. You have not even flown the ERJ-135. You managed to watch people who did fly it and perhaps talk to them. I am not sure that is a rational basis on which to judge an airplane that has had roughly a decade of development since those early certification days (in the case of the Legacy I believe it has had five years to mature and grow, so the airplane you saw on the ramp is not necessarily the airplane being sold right now).
ERJ-140 said:The airplane, being an airliner, was certified to fly anywhere from 2400 to 3600 hours per year. I am not sure that any airplane capable of doing so with the dispatch numbers the ERJ fleet posts could possibly be labled fragile.
ERJ-140 said:In discussions with a friend at Flight Options amon others I am told there are four configurations for the Legacy and that only the first early prototype numbers were posted to C&DD. Embraer has, apparently, and to their detriment, not bothered to correct the data that C&DD shows. I also noticed a Legacy for sale being advertised using C&DD data and it was a serial number down near the 500 range. Embraer already has nearly 850 ERJs and Legacys flying around the world, so it seems clear that C&DD is using old numbers that could have changed since 2000 (the year of the ERJ I saw for sale online).
ERJ-140 said:Again, I am not trying to become and advocate for the airplane by any means, but it seems quite clear that it is not the flimsy toy you claim it to be. It's not a Gulfstream, but it isn't meant to be. I don't particularly see anything wrong with that.
ERJ-140 said:As for contacting C&DD goes, I doubt it would be interested in taking unsolicited data from someone about an airplane it cares nothing about - assuming I was willing to spend the time to do it.
ERJ-140 said:Also, how is a G350, with twice the thrust, twice the weight going to operate for the same cost as the Legacy? Just doing numbers in my head shows that the Legacy burns 325 gallons per hour vs. 450 gph for the Gulfstream 350. Also a window on a G I am told costs about 50,000 to replace compared to about 5,000 for the EMB. Assuming this is even remotely accurate, how can the G350 even come close to the same operating costs? It seems to defy physics for an airplane twice as heavy to run at the same rate as the comparative jet.
The Legacy is the same type certificate as the ERJ-135, it is the ERJ-135BJ.
And yes, I’ve watched it grow.
I’ve watched it grow poorly engineered winglets which disrupted airflow and introduced yaw instability requiring the installation of vortlons and ventral strakes.
I also watched it grow fuel cells in every imaginable region of it’s wing and fuselage in order to make it’s range guarantees.
some_dude said:GV, great posts!
G100driver said:I must agree. It appears you have a great handle on this ..... vs that unfortunate Aurther Q comment.
I always enjoy reading your informed well thought out retorts. I always learn something new. Thank-you.![]()
ERJ-140 said:This is the frustrating part, however, and that is that the man can make mistakes about the airplane that are obvious even to a lowly former-RJ driver but the crowd still cheers. People are not being objective in this debate, they are simply taking the side of a guy they like even when he is wrong (perhaps rarely, but still not infallible). Try to read what is being said by both sides and call a spade a spade.
GVFlyer said:Keep in mind that Long Range Cruise for the G350 is over 8% faster than the Legacy while the 71,300 pound G350's hourly DOC is only 7% more than the 49,758 pound Legacy's. So actual operating costs are about
ERJ-140 said:(And yes, I have a sense of humor - I think I am the only person here who actually took the thread title for the tongue-in-cheek attempt at humor that it was.)
Yup, it's confirmed... ERJ-140 is IN FACT LegacyDriver... Who is also LegacyIIDriver who is also Skull-One, who is also vracui...G100driver said:LegacyDriver ... how nice it is to have you back.
Falcon Capt said:Yup, it's confirmed... ERJ-140 is IN FACT LegacyDriver... Who is also LegacyIIDriver who is also Skull-One, who is also vracui...
The guy just can't resist...
IP Addresses don't lie...
Going well... Tomorrow is the big day... It's been way too long, ready for it to be over!Gulfstream 200 said:Hey Capt, hows it going?
Nah, only the "tools" get called on the carpet...English said:On the other hand, another member of my family also has a screenname here. I'd hate to be called on the carpet just because we both have the same IP address.
THE BIG DAY, what might that be?Falcon Capt said:Going well... Tomorrow is the big day... It's been way too long, ready for it to be over!