I got an Aeronautical Science degree from ERAU Daytona in late 80s/early 90s. I went to Prescott for the first couple of years...Daytona is better.
Although I did a little training at a local FBO, most of my flight training was with ERAU instructors at ERAU. I have been a CFI at some FBOs, and was a CFI with ERAU for a couple of years after graduating.
Later, I went through USAF UPT (T-3, T-37, and T-38), then flew C-5s for 11 years. Now I work for an enormous U.S. cargo airline.
The FLIGHT training I received in the USAF far exceeds anything available to civilians. Why? Multimillion dollar jets, discipline, sink-or-swim (no extra training for the weak/no second chances), diversity of training (instruments, aerobatics, formation, low-level, combat training), standardization, and did I mention discipline? UPT costs about $5 million. There's no way any civilian program could compete with that.
That said, the flight training program at ERAU is the closest thing to the military available to civilians, in my opinion (I assume other strong aviation schools like UND are similar). For starters, the program was largely developed by retired military pilots. It's very well standardized with a lot of discipline. It ties in well with all the academics. Most of the CFIs have an aviation degree from ERAU. I've never seen that kind of quality at an FBO. I haven't seen all FBOs, but I've seen many. If I'm a pilot interviewer with a great airline, I'm definitely going to hire the guy with military flight training or a civilian aviation degree from a strong aviation school. I know what I'm getting. Why would I take a chance on hiring some guy who learned how to fly at Chuck's Flying School of the Ozarks? I have no idea how good his training was, or what kind of pilot he'd be. I'm not going to put some unknown in the front seat of our $150 million dollar jets. Are there any fools or tools coming out of ERAU or the military? Of course, but they're few and far between.
Moreover, the aviation ACADEMIC training I received at ERAU far and away exceeded anything I learned in the Air Force. It has been very helpful to my career, both in job interviews, and in the daily performance of my job. Does an aviation degree make me a better pilot than another pilot with a business degree? Who knows. But it does make me a better pilot than myself, had I not gotten an aviation degree. Who do you think makes a better CEO of Exxon...the guy with an art degree, or the guy with a geology degree, finance degree, or MBA? When your life is at stake and you require the best medical attention, do you want the doctor with an undergrad in air conditioning repair from ITT, or the guy with an undergrad in biochemistry from Stanford? I know who I'd want.
I agree with a previous poster; it's stupid to get a degree in something you're not going to do with your career. College isn't a square filler; it's preparation for what you're going to do with the rest of your life.
I don't know why SOME bash ERAU. I can tell you though that those people are not on the hiring boards in the military, or in the HR departments at major airlines, because those people have respect for ERAU. In 20 years of professional post-college aviation, valedictorian from ERAU has opened many doors for me. I wouldn't be where I am today without it.
It's a great education. I'd do it again in a heartbeat.
Good luck with your decision!