I havent seen a lot of ATP bashing, just one or two guys that probably couldnt hack getting 3 CFI tickets in 2 weeks. You pass the same FAA checkride as anyone else. As far as internet forums go (here and jetcareers) and the aviation world itself, ATP is a very reputable school. You dont see it getting bashed like DCA or RAA or some of the other highly expensive and unnecessary academies of which I have first hand experience. Im signed up for for the 4 day multi program and then the total CFI program for January. Since signing up with them I have been even more pleased with the way they do things- for the CFI program, they sent me a box full of almost every airplane PTS made, 2005 FARAIM, Av. Instructors Handbook, IFH, AFH, PHAK, C172 POH, their CFI program question booklet, PA44 training supplement, CFI oral exam guide and 3 ATP shirts, they would have sent me the PA44 POH but the printing factory is on backorder and they included a professional letter stating this, and that they would send one to me once they got them in stock (it dont matter because I have one already). Combined it has to be a value of somewhere between $200-250. And it was all included in the price of the program. Very nice.