Everyone has brought up some very good points about both airlines...some points are a little misleading at times, though. I do agree with the statement that you should go with who hires you first.
But, after reading all of the posts I can't help but wonder. If CHQ is so bad, as many posts are saying, then why is it that you never hear CHQ crews complaining? They always seem to be very happy with their QOL and contract and their company and growth prospects. These sentiments range from CHQ's most senior Captains to the most junior FOs.
You hear nothing but complaining on these websites from other airlines but you'll never meet a CHQ crew that denies a jumpseater, complains about pay, complains about schedules, complains too much about bases, complains about junior manning(CHQ doesn't have it), etc. etc.
So, when choosing any company to work for, not just an airline, it may be worth it to look to see how happy the employees are as whole. I'm sure it is just a product of coming to a website like these, so I don't like to this generalization...but it seems that CHQ seems happy with their place in the airline industry whiles others on this thread are looking for (or complaining about) greener pastures.
This is just an uneducated observation from me and has no statistical data to back it up.