If I was to be a member of any pilot labor organization it would have to be the IPA (Independent Pilots Group - UPS Pilot representation). They seem to be the most powerful union in aviation and from what I have heard they look after their charges most effectively and completely.
That's ONLY because they can afford to be. They represent branded employees, flying branded cargo. That is to say that every piece of cargo on the airplane has an airbill attached to it, and the name on that airbill matches the name on both the pilots cap AND paycheck.
When UPS started their "in-house" air ops, they relied exclusively on ACMI carriers, and none of them were worth a d*mn, IMHO. UPS didn't care, it was Alan T. McArtor, then-administrator of the FAA (and former D/O of FedEx) who
made them bring their airline ops in-house. Every single UPS pilot, from the newest new-hire to the #1 guy on the seniority list, owes that guy a great big kiss on the lips every payday, because without him, they'd all be flying MD-11's for $125/hr instead of $216, and there would be no job security beyond their next landing, wherever that might be.
Trust me, I was there...
Saying that working for one ACMI is better than working at another is like saying that working "Burger King" is better than working for "McDonalds." NONE of the ACMI carriers offers the pay, benefits, or stability of the "Big Two," nor can they. If and when the day ever comes when they do (or when the unions tell them they have to), watch out! The owners will move their capital out and start a new airline, taking only their "best" (read "hungriest, least likely to bee-yotch" pilots and starting them at new first-year pay rates.
Listening to some of you guys talk about how good "your" ACMI is compared to somebody else's is like listening to some 5-year-old on a Merry-Go-'Round bragging about how high "his" horsey is. You really don't get it...
Not sure what can kill an ACMI other than another ACMI... in the end, it's about providing airlines with excess capacity in peak demand moments so they don't have to have larger than necessary fleets.
OK, I'm calling bull$hit on that statement right here, right now! Gemini has been flying DHL cargo over the pond for years now. It's not "excess" cargo, it's DHL core business, and it's not happening only in "peak demand moments," but 7 days a week, 365 days a year for the last several years. Why? Because your guys will do it $100/hr cheaper than Astar will, and
they're already doing it for less than pilots at ABX, UPS, or FedEx. I don't entirely blame the pilots for that, they're in a tough position too. But don't even start with that "we're only doing what other people can't, or won't" stuff. You're bottom-feeders, and like a street-corner whore, your income and job-security are a function of what you'll do, and how cheap you'll do it.
Welcome to the streets. You have a lot to learn about this business, and I would suggest you start by
not drinking the Kool-Aid that your company is providing you...