Wow,
Interesting reads! I'll throw this out there: I'm based at one of Colgan's Mx bases and I flew a plane a cpl weeks ago with 6 MELs. Were they dire MELs? Absolutely not! I forget what they were, backlighting, a recirc fan, and an overhead bin I think... BFD! Some people might complain about that, but I'm not one of 'em. I'm obviously an F/O, but have never heard of any intimidation to fly a "broken" plane. Also, I flew b/w two of our Mx bases the other day with c-l-e-a-n/MEL-free airplanes.
That being said, AWAC is a great place, I've heard. A former student of mine wants to work there and asked me for a letter of recommendation. I happily wrote him one; I hope he gets the job. I'm from the Mid-Atlantic area and Colgan and AWAC would be the airlines I'd check out if I was a CFI all over again. To each his own.
I love the Saab, have great instrument skills, sleep in my bed 98% of the time, and really enjoy the people I work with. That's important to me. What's also important to me is getting PIC time and getting into a Boeing, Airbus, or Mad Dog sooner rather than later. I do not subscribe to the "go to a place where you could see yourself for 12 years" mentality. Some people might, and great for them.
I forget who started this thread, but whoever you are, good luck. I think you'll be happy at either AWAC or Colgan. Both are great places to work, but if you have a tough time choosing, flip a coin. If it lands for Colgan, I'll see ya on the line.
Snaab
P.S. The people who don't sound like they're 11 years old on this thread do bring up some valid points about both places, btw. To all the 11-year-old whiz kids who bitch about an MEL: get a life, go back to 'Riddle, hope I never fly with you.