You are talking about two different things. The Process Agreement for Single and Interim PBS is just as dead as all the other language in the 30 sections of the failed TA. That's to say that the only thing that is keeping it dead is mutual agreement. Do you honestly believe they are going to renegotiate all the language in every single section of the new TA? Or are the two MECs going to say, we don't need to change any sections dealing with hostages, CRAF, PAC check off, filling of vacancies, vacation accrual, definitions, travel expenses, moving expenses, deadheading, miscellaneous flying, supervisory duty, training, hours of service, leaves of absence, physical exams, foreign flying, investigation and discipline, grievances, system board of adjustment, furlough and recall, line check pilots, etc. Off course they are just going to re-TA those items! But one MEC decided to re-hash the PBS disagreement rather than just agree on a previously agreed to process.
So now with the other MEC having taken that position, the xjt MEC decided it's in their pilots best interest to give them a vote on smartpref. And if it's as bad as you guys say, then you have nothing to worry about because the pilots will vote it down.
Once again, an XJT looks down his nose at a ASA guy. We've been through the mock bid process. You will not get the involvement that you think you will. Pilots are people no matter what company they work for. (Except for XJT pilots. You guys are special.) You will not get the group to get educated. They will vote how they are told they should vote and given your responses on the PBS issue, you've been sold half truths and told to understand it in a way that benefits certain people.
Your line construction process is a global process. You mitigate it greatly with a crap shoot with a Wild West type of open time. You're being sold a global system based on your line bid system except the open time process will not help in a global PBS system. There is a reason why every pilot group that decides to negotiate a system, chooses a nonglobal system. Yet, XJT pilots are special, everyone else is stupid. So your guys run down the road to a global system.
I did not argue two separate issues. I spoke of the PBS process agreement. It was written to go along with a JCBA, not during a Section 6 negotiation. The process says you stay on a line bid system and develop a PBS system after a TA ratification become a JCBA. Why is your group selling out line bid when you could have two more years of your precious line bidding? And yeah, I understand better than you'd like to think.