hydroflyer
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2003
- Posts
- 254
question to all of you pro-instructor people. when i was a student working on my instrument rating, we did no real weather flying, very little actual, few "real" instrument approaches, and minimal airways flying. i learned the basic skills that we all learn getting our instrument ticket, but only since i have been flying in the right seat have i actually flown weather many times, real IFR, real approaches, airway flying, and procedures specific to commercial flying.
Going by this quote I would guess that you did your training down south. Even so, I think several students down south (Florida for example) are getting the short end of the stick when it comes to actual instrument experience. Just the other day I heard a training flight practicing holding about 1,000' below a cloud deck, around 3,000'. Personally, I would have climbed up into the clouds with the student to get the real experience. There was no airspace problems with doing so. Maybe that instructor as well as yours did not have much actual and was hesitant about taking someone up into it.
Don't start attacking the instuctor route on IFR experience based on what your instructor did. I gained just as much actual experience instructing as I have flying freight. When the weather got low, our instructors would call up the instrument students, get them down to the airport and we would go practice approaches to airports with the lowest weather. If no students could come down, then we would pair up and split the cost of the flight and practice approaches ourselves, just for the actual. And by practicing approaches, we rarely climbed more than 2,000' AGL for very long, which kept us in the soup for extended periods of time. Also since instructing is part 91, you can legally make an approach with 1/4 mile visibility, knowing you won't break out, but show the student what it would be like. Can't do that 121 or 135 without higher CAT certification. Flying around at several hundred miles per hour going from city to city usually means you don't spend much time actual. How often do you log more than 1 hour of actual on a duty day? I had some co-workers with over 100 hours of actual by the time they had 1400tt. You just need to go get it. Living in Florida or somewhere down south is not a killer, you may just need to do most of the instrument flying in the morning with the lower clouds before they burn off.
Instructing has proved very valuable to me, especially in giving me good habits that I constantly had to remind my students to do. It truly is amazing what you learn instructing.