Tough call; true but not accurate
Tough call. Without a crystal ball, no one can tell you what to do. However, I'd definitely stick with CAL for a couple of reasons. First, I think the 121 world is at the bottom of a cycle. I don't think it'll get any worse. Second, there's a good chance that over your career, CAL pilots will negotiate some big improvements. Thirdly, NJA is about to enter into a deal that could tie them up for another 8.5 years. They could really get hammered by inflation. What you see, is all you'll be getting for about 10 years.
NetJets' QOL is good, but a 121 carrier can offer a lot of things that the NJA guys can NEVER have based on the kind of operation it is. You'll be cleaning planes, toting bags and flying into tiny little airports for the rest of your life. Doesn't matter how senior you get. You're never going to fly high time turn-arounds 12 days/month.
As far as commuting. Move to your base and give yourself the biggest increase in QOL imagineable. Do it while you and your family are young.
I guess I would ask myself what
kind of flying do I want to do?
A very wise and senior NJA pilot once asked me, "Do you really want to fly the "big" rigs? if so, move on, you'll never be happy. He then put on a Jimmy Buffett CD over the plane's surround sound system as we waited for pax.
With any job there are parts of a job that are a chore.
We are
responsible for cleaning planes,
occasionallytoting bags, and flying into a
variety (circling at night in weather) of airports.
Eight years ago, I left the excellent group of pilots at ASA, for another excellent group of aviators at EJA. Since then, I've been to every state in the union.
BTW they let us fly into those "big airplane" airports too.
Also, we have the ability to "tip" folks at those little airports to help us with those chores.
One last thing, our union. Best group of leaders
I have ever seen. QOL, benefits, future, pay and job security have all been vastly improved and secured because of their hard work.
Every retired ALPA/Airline pilot I have flown with are in awe of what's been accomplished here.