Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Why is SKW getting rid of the CMR planes

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web
WorldOnTime said:
Yeah, you Comair guys are one to talk. I seem to remember something about taking a pay freeze (read:concessions) in order to secure shiny new jets. Just a week or so after your lovely MEC sent us a nice letter and sticker...."Comair pilots support ASA pilots"

That's a good one. Pilot A from a group too weak to negotiate its own agreement takes a shot at pilot B from a group that paid dearly to set the bar for signing, at the point of a sword, an agreeement to prevent the transfer of flying to pilot A's airline because, to paraphrase WalMart "they'll simply work for less."

I hope those SkyWest pillows taste as good as the ones you're used to.......
 
Last edited:
Actually talked to Brad Holt in the LAX break room last week for over an hour. We asked him about the Comair planes. He said it had to do with the ASA deal, but was a matter of cleaning up the books; returning expensive leased planes for one's with a better lease rates, not necessarily anyones gain or loss. He agreed that he didn't think the pay proposal would be approved so we asked him then what. He said that maybe next time the 1.2% wouldn't be on the table, everyone else is taking concessions these days and SkyWest is still offering a small increase (moving the ball in the right direction so to speak). He said he understood people making a stand on principle i.e. 50-99 seat pay, but in this environment those who stand on principle "Will fall by the wayside." He emphasized what happened to AWAC and said he had serious doubts about weather on not Comair will survive. Just casual chat in a quiet breakroom not a PR job delivered to the masses, there was only me the FO and the FA in the room. FWIW I voted no.
 
Jon Rivoli said:
He said he understood people making a stand on principle i.e. 50-99 seat pay, but in this environment those who stand on principle "Will fall by the wayside." He emphasized what happened to AWAC and said he had serious doubts about weather on not Comair will survive. Just casual chat in a quiet breakroom not a PR job delivered to the masses, there was only me the FO and the FA in the room. FWIW I voted no.

The horrible thing is that the best chance for Comair surviving, probably rides on whether or not ASA can finally negotiate their contract or if Skywest can get their pay for the 70 and 90 seater increased.

I don't think Comair pilots have much confidence that either one of these things will EVER HAPPEN.

So because our Labor Costs are too high at Comair, we may "FALL BY THE WAYSIDE".

Well, it's been a great career.

Jon, thanks for voting No.

Unfortunately you're just one voice, and we at Comair "TAKING OUR STAND ON PRINCIPLE" will probably "FALL BY THE WAYSIDE" like the Skywest CP said.

We're glad we've held the bar so high so long, so the rest of you could grow, but unfortunately we're gonna lose our jobs because of it.

HOPE YOU'RE ALL APPRECIATIVE.

WE DESERVE THANKS,

Jet
 
Last edited:
Those who stand on principle "will fall by the wayside"

Jon Rivoli said:
Actually talked to Brad Holt in the LAX break room last week for over an hour. We asked him about the Comair planes. He said it had to do with the ASA deal, but was a matter of cleaning up the books; returning expensive leased planes for one's with a better lease rates, not necessarily anyones gain or loss. He agreed that he didn't think the pay proposal would be approved so we asked him then what. He said that maybe next time the 1.2% wouldn't be on the table, everyone else is taking concessions these days and SkyWest is still offering a small increase (moving the ball in the right direction so to speak). He said he understood people making a stand on principle i.e. 50-99 seat pay, but in this environment those who stand on principle "Will fall by the wayside." He emphasized what happened to AWAC and said he had serious doubts about weather on not Comair will survive. Just casual chat in a quiet breakroom not a PR job delivered to the masses, there was only me the FO and the FA in the room. FWIW I voted no.

skywest.alpa.org


wow! let's just fly for $10/hr...wtfo?
we know management has no principles in aviation but thanks for making the point. this is a f-ing joke. dang management azz clowns
 
Last edited:
jetflyer said:
The scary thing is that we know that the ASA pilots will do whatever it takes to get airplanes - including delaying their contract on purpose and hoping Comair pilots would have voted "NO" to a pay freeze so that Comair's 70's would be SHIFTED TO ASA at the expense of 200+ Comair pilot jobs.

YGTBSM, either that was intended as TIC or that was one of the most rediculous statements I have ever read on this forum.

The ASA pilots do not have a track record of groveling for growth, unlike others.
 
Several ASA pilots have told me they really don't think it's in their best interests to get a "pay raise" or definitely not to "strike" because they think it will leave them exposed to LOSING AIRCRAFT or NOT GETTING FUTURE AIRCRAFT.

MANY ASA PILOTS think dragging out their negotiations and being kept FROZEN at their current rates might be in their best interests for the long term. What do you call this?

I can't believe they're looking out for their best interests so they won't SHRINK and can still get future aircraft!? The nerve! Unbelievable!

Sometimes I feel like some ASA pilots will only be happy if Comair is dismantled and all of Comair's planes go to ASA. Then they'll finally "THANK COMAIR FOR EVERYTHING THEY'VE DONE FOR THE INDUSTRY".

I was serious,
Jet
 
Last edited:
Wow Im glad I dont work for either one of your carriers.

Sounds like a bunch of A$$holes work at both places
 
DHPFLYN said:
Wow Im glad I dont work for either one of your carriers.

Sounds like a bunch of A$$holes work at both places

Which combination might you be talking about? ASA, Comair, SkyWest?


Just curious if I'm an asshole.............................(can I say that? Oh. it looks like I can.)


AF :cool:
 
jetflyer said:
MANY ASA PILOTS think dragging out their negotiations and being kept FROZEN at their current rates might be in their best interests for the long term. What do you call this?

I can't believe they're looking out for their best interests so they won't SHRINK and can still get future aircraft!? The nerve! Unbelievable!

Sometimes I feel like some ASA pilots will only be happy if Comair is dismantled and all of Comair's planes go to ASA. Then they'll finally "THANK COMAIR FOR EVERYTHING THEY'VE DONE FOR THE INDUSTRY".

I was serious,
Jet
Jet, your whining is really going over the top. If you have 5,000 hours, I doubt you will ever see a furlough notice. My friends at Comair are not nearly as worried as you are because they know Comair is not going anywhere. As long as Delta has a CVG operation they need Comair. Comair's costs are low and were not significantly effected by your concessions. Your concessions were political - and it was sucessful. Your concessions broke up the alliance between two of the largest Delta Connection pilot groups.

Comair grew into flying that had been performed by ACA pilots, Delta pilots, ASA pilots and others. With the exception of a few Delta pilots, you did not see us whining on this board despite the fact that a third of C Concourse in ATL was lined up with CMR jets. To this day, I think Comair still has more junior Captains than ASA has.

ASA pilots do not allocate the flying, so I don't know why your whining to us. Go scream at Mesa, Gerald Grinstien, or Duane Woerth. Thanks to your union not allowing any of us to have scope we have a competitive race to the bottom.

BUT - our pay is so low that the cost per hour is negligible when compared to the cost of operating the airplane and fuel. No airline is going to allocate airplanes based on $4 an hour. Just as Jerry Atkin told our pilots who are worried that SkyWest will replace us - "The airplanes will go where there is operational need for the airplanes."

Proof of this can be found in the fact that ASA turned down concessions (when Barnette asked us to come out of section 6 negotiations) yet we still got the airplanes.

After your pilot groups little bit of predatory bargaining to scope some growth at the expense of ASA, you dare to come here and whine when it did not work out? You say you are serious, but what you write is so silly that it has to be flame bait. If it is not flame bait you need to realize that predatory bargaining never works out. There is always another pilot group willing to stab you in the back - after all you stabbed them first. ALPA National has a duty to stop this crap, but has forgot everything they learned about alter ego bargaining.

In the mean time, ASA pilots have done nothing. We have not had a TA presented to us for a vote. We have picketed and are going to picket again this weekend. If you would like to come down to the Great Georgia Airshow in Peachtree City we will gladly get you in a rotation, feed you and say thanks for your support. And the SkyWest pilots voted "NO!" - with a pretty good margin. So Comair Pilots are the only pilots included in your complaints that have voted for concessions for airplanes. Make no mistake about it, you were voting for growth airplanes, with your pay contingent on certain fleet targets.

Along those lines, you will be glad to know that ASA's contract effort appears to be moving along better now that SkyWest owns us. There has been a house cleaning over at our General Offices which has removed many of the road blocks in our effort to reach an agreement.

So use that PIC time you gained at CMR to fill out applications, or if you did not upgrade in 5,000 hours after your instructing gig, try to get in an upgrade class fast. Either way you should have your head in the books, not on Flight Info.

~~~^~~/~ (Fins with the knife in his back)
 
Last edited:
~~~^~~~ said:
So Comair Pilots and the Delta boys are the only pilots included in your complaints that have voted for concessions for airplanes.


When did the Delta pilots ever vote for concessions for airplanes? We took concessions a year ago, yes, but it sure wasn't in return for any airplanes.
 
MANY ASA PILOTS think dragging out their negotiations and being kept FROZEN at their current rates might be in their best interests for the long term. What do you call this?

Can you deny SOME ASA pilots are saying this? I don't think so. I know you've heard ASA pilots say they think delaying their contract until it's a better environment to negotiate is in their best interests.

These pilots don't want to be passed over for growth and don't want to have their assets taken away from them because of high labor costs.

It's horrible they're worried about losing aircraft by increasing their pay! Unbelievable! Why aren't these ASA PILOTS thinking of other pilot groups first!!!!!!!!!!!!??

I've been hearing this from ASA pilots for years. You've probably said yourself a time or too.

To me these ASA pilots are more than willing to keep their PAY FREEZE enacted until there are better times for Delta.

Our LABOR COSTS at Comair are still the highest in the Delta system. SORRY WE GET PAID MORE THAN YOU.

ARE YOU JEALOUS?? Is that why you whine so much ~~^^~^~~&~ or whatever the hell your name is!?

Oh and you're WRONG about our pay freeze. We were worried about getting liquidated FIRST AND FOREMOST.

EVERYONE was worried about what would happen to us if we voted "NO". EVERYONE at COMAIR.

Why do you think many, many senior Captains voted YES. They didn't want a pay freeze. They didn't care about growth aircraft. They were worried about the future of Comair. Things looked VERY, VERY BLEAK with a "NO" vote.

You're all too MORONIC TO COMPREHEND. THAT'S OK, WE FEEL FOR YOU.

There was a real threat of many of us losing jobs and maybe being liquidated. Everyone was talking about this at Comair. EVERYONE.

YOU AND EVERY OTHER PILOT GROUP ARE MORONS IF YOU DON'T SEE THAT WE WERE WORRIED ABOUT LOSING JOBS BY VOTING "NO".

You've never had the TARGET ON YOUR BACKS. YOU CAN'T POSSIBLY UNDERSTAND. GET SOME BALLS AND MAYBE ONE DAY YOU WILL, BUT I DOUBT IT.

Well our labor costs ARE STILL THE HIGHEST and we're still getting sold off plane by plane. Where will it stop? Nobody knows. Plus my job is in jeopardy. I flew freight before coming to Comair and I don't have PIC turbine time.

Jet
 
Last edited:
JetFlyer, you are retarded.

These pilots don't want to be passed over for growth and don't want to have their assets taken away from them because of high labor costs.

EVERYONE was worried about what would happen to us if we voted "NO". EVERYONE at COMAIR.


What's the difference?

You say comair took a pay freeze because "EVERYONE was worried about what would happen to us if we voted no" and now you are shouting out that ASA should stop worrying about being "passed over for growth", demand a pay raise or strike!


A couple of things: (1) I do NOT want anyone to lose a job! Not you, or any other pilot...not even the janitor! I do NOT want anyone to take a pay cut...pay cuts hurt (no matter how much you earn).

(2) We have not had a vote at ASA...I have not agreed to work for less (or more) and I have not had the option to vote for a strike. In fact, I just got a letter saying a strike was not even a legal option right now.

(3) I had no control over skywest buying ASA. The skywest pilots had no control over it either. I do not think skywest bought ASA because we are better or cheaper or any reason like that. I think they bought ASA because they wanted Atlanta!

I think Comair is catching a bad deal. Honestly, I was worried when there was talk of selling us. We didn't know what to expect. At the time, we thought Comair was getting a better deal and it was going to be bad for us. We didn't know (and still don't) how things were going to to play out.

Again, I am sorry if ANYONE loses a job.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top Bottom