hockeypilot44
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2005
- Posts
- 893
Really? Because that scope clause is what is keeping Midwest pilots from being recalled ahead of an actual seniority list integration.
And as for RAH pilots putting Midwest pilots on the street...just look at Frontier. Those pilots have not been displaced or furloughed at the hand of RAH pilots. Is it that we like the F9 pilots better? Is it because they are so much closer to RAH pilots in pay than to Midwest pilots? Is it because RAH pilots want to fly the Airbus, but not a 717?
No. The difference is that Frontier was, is, and will continue to be a viable airline. Midwest was a great airline, and had a tremendous product, but that product was no longer producing. Frontier pilots are receiving the same treatment that Midwest pilots are. Each is stuck in their situation until the SLI is complete. Midwest pilots can't be recalled to RAH and Frontier pilots can't be recalled either. If saving labor cost was BB's ultimate goal, why haven't Frontier pilots been furloughed, and Airbuses sold or returned?
Midwest Airlines could not sustain itself. Customers loved it, pilots took pride in a job well done, and everyone earned their place in the colorful history of our industry. But midwest took a wrong turn at the hands of management. They wound up with a single fleet type that proved trapping. The plane could not fly long range, it was no longer produced, there were few aftermarket airframes available, and the plane itself limited the amount of revenue that could be generated. Choosing the 717 was not necessarily anyone's fault, but it ended up putting too many limitations on a business that needed to rapidly adapt to an economy and industry in turmoil. The 717 smothered Midwest. Airtran reluctantly had to find a different airframe to meet its expansion needs. MIdwest either didn't or couldn't.
If labor cost was the only problem with Midwest, why didn't Bedford try to keep the 717 and have RAH pilots fly it? 25 secured airframes is a lot easier to begin business with than sourcing E190's one by one from various owners and operators.
Midwest was broken. No one blames the pilots. You did everything you ought to have done to keep Midwest great. But that doesn't change the fact that the business model could not be fixed.
Midwest pilots are on the street because their business was coming apart, and because RAH pilots have a solid scope clause that prevents Midwest pilots from flying an RAH aircraft before integration. If the Midwest business was functional like Frontier, the Midwest pilots would still be flying 717's until the seniority integration, and most likely after, as well.
Everyone overlooks the fact that no F9 guys have been put on the street by RAH pilots. Just stop and think why, and then consider what makes F9 different from YX. RAH is a common denominator, but a common denominator that yields two wildly opposite outcomes can be considered irrelevant to the outcomes. RAH has treated both pilot groups with the same legal viewpoint. It stands to reason that the difference in status between Midwest pilots and Frontier pilots has to do with Frontier and Midwest themselves, not RAH.
There is no need for F9 pilots to "watch out", because no one is gunning for their jobs, just like no one is or was gunning for Midwest jobs. I don't blame Midwest guys for being upset. They are proud of their airline, and each of us has our judgment clouded by pride.
Were you working at Republic when the Shuttle America Saab captains were in training to be 170 captains? Do you remember Wayne Heller's, "No harm, no foul" letter? Were you with Chautauqua when the company fired every single Saab pilot that was still on probation to avoid retraining costs? The Republic recalls have less than a few months vested in the company. They are all at year 1 pay and ready to happily come back to work. Do you remember petition boy? Bedford has absolutely no respect for you contract what-so-ever. Your scope clause is just as worthless as every other part of it and just as worthless as mainline's. Like I said, you will find that out some day when you guys are not the cheapest anymore. I stand by that comment.