No offense Sewept, but an ILS is an ILS or VOR is a VOR, when was the last time you saw an airline guy shoot a circling(most airlines won't allow it) or an NDB again most airlines won't allow it. Ask an airline gut to figure out fuel or flight plan or a simple thing like know where when and how to get coffee, ice and papers EFFICIENTLY. ETC, ETC.
Look I think airline guys have experience sure, however if I had to pick I would take a Corporate guy or girl who's been doing it from the start. They were dedicated to Corporate from the start.
Look at it this way, its not just having a person next to you to help you with (as you put it) the night garbage weather while circling. What if you also had the person next to you who did there job very efficiently(coffe, ice, papers,catering issues, cleaning the plane, stocking, ordering fuel, ETC.) and allowed you to get out quick to avoid the weather here, there or avoid slot time issues and still assisting you with no problems on approaches late.
No offense Art, but I've shot more than my share of night, garbage weather, circling approaches here at Netjets. I want the most EXPERIENCED pilots we can hire sitting in my right or left seat. Airline guys suit me just fine.[/quote]