The "jumpseat" at AirTran is free. Period. We allow one jumpseater just like the majority of other carriers out there. The difference is that as a 121/135 pilot you can on-the-spot non rev for $25.00 - if the jumpseat is taken. This is the way management wants it. Do we like it? NO! But we are doing what we can as a union to go back to the open cabin policy, but until then our policy is still better than 90% of the airlines out there. I do not believe that any non AirTran pilot has the right to say that this is "unfair". Bad timing? .. YES. Bad PR for commuters?.. YES Unfair?... NO.
As a commuter I sympathize, and throughout my career I have commuted to domiciles all over the country, and still commute to this day. I have been left behind while an empty airplane pulled away from the gate many times. This is/was during a period when I worked for carriers that allowed all the jumpseaters we could take. I certainly NEVER ever blamed the pilots for "justifying" it, or got on a message board even remotely implying that it was BS, after all WE took unlimited jumpseaters. Its not fair?! So what?! It is/was part of the "commuter blues", and I deal/dealt with it. Management ultimately decides who gets on their airplanes for free.... period.
Our union is working on this, and hopefully we will go back to a open cabin someday, until then, I will ALWAYS non-rev and leave the jumpseat to offline pilots. I will even sit on the Flight Attendant seat if it gets you a seat onboard and off to work.