That's very interesting. How recent were these observations from the FSI instructors? I went through the X type course in CMH last June, and I didn't have any problems whatsoever. In fact, I'd put up anybody in my new-hire class against a seasoned NJA veteran in that type course. Actually, that's exactly what happened, because we were teamed up with Capt upgrades (mostly coming from the Ultra) for the course. Guess what? Out of that entire type class, the only guys to fail their sim check rides were 2 Capt upgrades (both guys had been at NJA for approx 5 years). The checkrides flown were exactly the same for new-hires or experienced Capt upgrades. Do you really think that the quality of new-hires has dropped that much in a few months time?
I can probably give you a little insight to this, and why you're not too impressed, with a little dose of my personal history at NJA. I was hired last May, went to X type school in June, sat for 3 months, company aircraft training in Sept, and have been sitting on my a$$ ever since, waiting for IOE. Now, I don't know how "normal" this is in the fractional world, but it is unheard of at any other of my past flying jobs. When I finally get the call to report for IOE, I'm guessing that I'll be just a bit rusty, and maybe a little behind the power curve (so to speak). I can study all the manuals I have, and stare at the cockpit poster for hours a day, but it doesn't take the place of actually flying the jet, and working on the line.
IMHO, the NetJets training department is to blame for this, and not the new-hire pilot. We're trained at FSI, and then sit around for months while our skills deteriorate on this new aircraft we just learned. Obviously, the NJA training dept wasn't set up to handle the number of new-hire pilots that have joined the ranks this year. Couple this with all the bypass guys upgrading, and you have IOE/LCA Capts that are working non-stop. Maybe training some more IOE/LCA Capts is a step in the right direction? Certainly, having a guy sit around for 6 months waiting for IOE, and then complaining about his performance isn't the right answer. But that's just my opinion....I could be wrong.